Hua Shan Luan Jian: Swordmasters

[Dennis Chen]

Dugu Qiu Bai. Wong Chongyang. Zhang Sanfeng.

FIGHT!

[Dennis Chen]

Nothing? Well, in my opinion, it would be Wong Chongyang, because, in the book it says that he is undefeated.

[Wu Xing]

Nothing? Well, in my opinion, it would be Wong Chongyang, because, in the book it says that he is undefeated.

Many persons in this world are undefeated.

To me, I like all three but I cannot decide/say who is the best. They are all the best. Remember, once a talent person starts fighting a stronger opponent, he/she become stronger too.

[Tazzy1972]

WCY for me

[Thai guy]

Dugu Qiu Bai. Wong Chongyang. Zhang Sanfeng.

FIGHT!

I have a serious doubt over the ability of Z3F in comparison with the other two fighters. We hardly know the exact ability of Dugu QiuBai. Judging from what was written in the cave where YG found his sword, perhaps Dugu QiuBai might be the best fighter.

[Ken Cheng]

I have a serious doubt over the ability of Z3F in comparison with the other two fighters. We hardly know the exact ability of Dugu QiuBai. Judging from what was written in the cave where YG found his sword, perhaps Dugu QiuBai might be the best fighter.

On the contrary, I give much more credence to the greatness of Cheung 3 Fung's martial arts, which were evident for us to see, than to the speculative greatness of Dook Goo Kau Bai.

[machiavelli]

On the contrary, I give much more credence to the greatness of Cheung 3 Fung's martial arts, which were evident for us to see, than to the speculative greatness of Dook Goo Kau Bai.

Speculations excites us all. Wouldn't it be boring if everything was proven and we can no longer speculate?

[ToOn99]

I have a serious doubt over the ability of Z3F in comparison with the other two fighters. We hardly know the exact ability of Dugu QiuBai. Judging from what was written in the cave where YG found his sword, perhaps Dugu QiuBai might be the best fighter.

What if everything written in the cave was from an insane guy who was obsessing about being invincible? (Murong Fu maybe since the theory was around in the past ) It is possible since the theory (not really theory though) he wrote in the cave was rather extreme but of course it is gonna boost the practitioner’s power.

[Ren Wo Xing]

Author's intent, author's intent. You can find 'evidence' for anything. If I wanted to, using your 'logic', I could say things like...Xiao Feng is (going off the DFBB thread a bit) actually gay. That's why he spends so much time with the guys, and doesn't care about females that much at all. If I -really- wanted to, I could probably find enough 'evidence' to support the theory. But it's a waste of time. Author's intent.

[Zhuge Liang]

WCY & Z3F would probably meet at the bottom of the mountain and get so caught up in their taoist chit chat they forget all about DGQB.

[Vicious]

WCY & Z3F would probably meet at the bottom of the mountain and get so caught up in their taoist chit chat they forget all about DGQB.

that's so true though, DGQB is the only one would care about it. the other two probably wouldn't even show up unless there's another reason to.

[rabadi]

WCY & Z3F would probably meet at the bottom of the mountain and get so caught up in their taoist chit chat they forget all about DGQB.

Agree
Anyway, I go with Z3F if the fight happens.