Continuation of HSDS?

[Newbie7]

Hi,
the link below looks like jin yong new works?

http://qiqi.com/cgi-bin/bk2.pl?fd1=b...fd3=jyx&in=jyx

Hav it been discussed before?

one is abt FCY and the other looks like a continuation of HSDS

[wkeej]

sorry, my mandarin is weak. anything about xiao zhao?

[yittz]

Thanks for the link. Obviously not written by JY no? I don't think many here have read these two stories.

An expected reply for Wkeej , Xiao Zhao was not mentioned in the first two chapters. But there have been references to many characters in Wudang, Ming cult left from HSDS, and Duan, OuYang decendents from ROCH. As well as a cheeky girl named Zhang, no surprises to where she came from.

[Xin Zhi Zhu]

huh? can explain wat is the link about? and wat does it says? sorry fot the trouble...

[Du Gu seeking a win]

Hi,
the link below looks like jin yong new works?

http://qiqi.com/cgi-bin/bk2.pl?fd1=b...fd3=jyx&in=jyx

Hav it been discussed before?

one is abt FCY and the other looks like a continuation of HSDS

*

That's a fake Jin Yong, he uses the pseudonym (pen name) : Jin Yong Xin (Jin Yong New)

The other story is about the origins of the books Jiu Yin & Jiu Yang (Shen Jing)

-

[wkeej]

As well as a cheeky girl named Zhang, no surprises to where she came from.

zwj's and zm's daughter?

[yittz]

Eh to be honest I am not actually sure, just speculation, didnt read it closely or far.

To those who have read these two novels by fake Jin Yong, what are your opinions of it?

I find it rather boring, and it seems to try to incorporate Jin Yong's ideas and use his characters too much instead of developing new chars and ideas. Tries too hard to make the connection with JY making bits far-fetched. Good effort nonetheless.

[HuangYushi]

To those who have read these two novels by fake Jin Yong, what are your opinions of it?

Tried Jiuyin/Jiuyang a while back but couldn't get past the first couple of chapters. Reads like a poorly-written piece of fan-fiction to me. Painful.

[wkeej]

Eh to be honest I am not actually sure, just speculation, didnt read it closely or far.

btw, what does this zhang daughter do in the story? was she trained by zsf, zhuo zhiruo and lady yang? did she went to persia to visit xiao zhao?

actually, in my own story telling (somewhere in "fan fictions"), zwj also has a daughter. but it is with zhuo zhiruo.

[yittz]

I dunno, didnt read enough to find out. Ditto what HYS said, so cant be bothered to find out, sorry. Hope ZWJ rescues XZhao, but unrealistic I think, given the personality of ZWJ, and the situation of Xiao Zhao.