ROCH controversy

[Ren Wo Xing]

Bad taste? Did you SEE the MCF in the Mainland adaptation?

[Huumanshadow]

Dude, the MCF for the 2002 LOCH was smoking hot, i say she was the hottest actress in the serie. HR was cute and adorable, but man....MCF can put her nails on me anytime...anyplace...anywhere...

[Ken Cheng]

Despite that casting decision, however, the middle-aged Mui Chiu Fung who'd endured such hardships in Mongolia and had twisted her physiology with errant 9 Yum White Bone Claws practice was supposed to be an ugly hag. Her youthful beauty was a thing of the past by then.

[LuNaR]

i saw the roch 94 version, and she is u-g-l-y

[Xin Zhi Zhu]

Is Yelu Qi linked to tiemujin?
and initially he liked a girl by the surname of wanyan.. how's she related to the wanyan family? wanyan honglie's niece?

[Ken Cheng]

Is Yelu Qi linked to tiemujin?

Yeh Lut Chai's father, Yeh Lut Chor Choi, was one of Genghis Khan's most important civic ministers. It was Yeh Lut Chor Choi, in fact, who persuaded Genghis Khan not to exterminate the Chinese population and reduce the Chinese Central Plains into a pasture, but to enslave and tax the Chinese population and leave their land intact. Yeh Lut Chor Choi and Yeh Lut Chai were descendants of Yeh Lut Hung Gei...the Khitan king who befriended Kiu Fung in DGSD. The Khitan Liao Empire had been destroyed by the Juchen Jin Empire over 100 years earlier.

and initially he liked a girl by the surname of wanyan.. how's she related to the wanyan family? wanyan honglie's niece?

Yes. Yeun Nan Ping was most definitely connected in some way to the Juchen royal family Yeun Nan, but her exact connection to Yeun Nan Hung Lit is unknown.

Ironically, Yeun Nan Ping became the sworn sister of Yeung Gor, whose father Yeung Hong had also been known as Yeun Nan Hong. They could have been "cousins" (although not by blood, since Yeung Hong was not a blood descendant of the Yeun Nans, but an adopted child).

[Siven]

Bad taste? Did you SEE the MCF in the Mainland adaptation?

The actress chosen for that role is an accomplished dancer famous for emotive dances that centered around hand movement.

[Linda]

geez i read the book but i never knew hyc liked mcf, i guess i didn't read closely enough.

about the sibiling thing, if two people who are only related through adoption, but was raised side by side since infant as brothers and sisters, would u frown on their sexual relationship?

like Autume Story of korea, alot of people still found it incest and was disgusted while most where okay with it because they weren't related.

if we apply the same logic in xln and yg case, they 'matured' (yg grew from child to adulthood) along side each other in the teacher/student or bro/sis sense, do u frown on them?

[kidd]

geez i read the book but i never knew hyc liked mcf, i guess i didn't read closely enough.

This plot is only in the 3rd edition of LOCH.

[Linda]

oh great! i own the first edition, since viet people don't bother to retranslate edited versions.

[LuNaR]

why did jin yong decide to change i nthe 3rd version to make hys like mcf?

[Siven]

why did jin yong decide to change i nthe 3rd version to make hys like mcf?

One possible explanation is that doing so would make HYS's earlier punishment of his students when it was discovered that MCF stole 9YZJ more understandable.