Battle of the Century : Jin Yong's Best VS Gu Long's Best

[Temujin]

The two Floral Princesses aren't in Gu Long's list? Lian Xing can be out but i thought Yao Yue is at least on par with Yan Nantian if not better.

I think chicken is using the most reliable list, Tigerwong's Gulong Top 10 and Laviathan's Jin Yong Top 10. If I recalled correctly Yaoyue ranks just under Yan Nantian so she is not on the top 10 list.

So are we playing or not ?

[chickenfeet]

We have 4 people so far, anyone else want to play ?

[PJ]

hey chicken, Zhang Sanfeng is ranked on the same level as Zhang Wuji. Personally I am a bit sick of ZSF by now, since he was in 2 of the 3 games. On the other hand Wuji has been lonely just watching us play. Why not give Wuji an opportunity here?

[chickenfeet]

hey chicken, Zhang Sanfeng is ranked on the same level as Zhang Wuji. Personally I am a bit sick of ZSF by now, since he was in 2 of the 3 games. On the other hand Wuji has been lonely just watching us play. Why not give Wuji an opportunity here?

Good suggestion PJ. Here is the new list. Are you in or out ?


OK, here are the two teams :

JIN YONG TOP 10

1. Sweeper Monk 20
2. Xiao Yao Elders 20
3. Shi PoTian 20
4. Dugu Qiubai 20
5. Xu Zhu 20
6. Wang Chong Yang 20
7. Huang shang 20
8. Guo Jing 20
9. Yang Guo 20
10. Zhang Wuji 20


GU LONG TOP 10

1. Xiao Yao Hou 20
2. Dong Guo Xian Sheng 20
3. Shen Lang 20
4. Water Matriarch 20
5. Yu Pei Yu 20
6. Xie Xiao Feng 20
7. Ding Peng 20
8. Old Man Gong 20
9. Yan 13 20
10. Yan Nantian 20

[blueberry]

chicken, I'll play...but I prefer to wait. Too many games can make me get bored fast.

[PJ]

why the hell not. your call.

[kidd]

Overall I prefer the Gu Long fighters, but Shi Po Tian is in the Jin Yong group. So, no choice. If I'm going to play, I'll have to support the Jin Yong group. That's sad.

[chickenfeet]

Ok we have 6 players, let's get it on!

REMEMBER YOU MUST PICK SIDE, ONCE YOU PICK ONE SIDE, YOU MUST ALWAYS VOTE + FOR YOUR TEAM AND - FOR THE OPPOSITE TEAM, THE 4 ROTATIONAL RULE APPLIES, NO ALTERNATING VOTES NEEDED AT THIS TIME

FOR A COMPLETE RULES GO TO PAGE 1

JIN YONG TOP 10

1. Sweeper Monk 20
2. Xiao Yao Elders 20
3. Shi PoTian 20
4. Dugu Qiubai 20
5. Xu Zhu 20
6. Wang Chong Yang 20
7. Huang shang 20
8. Guo Jing 20
9. Yang Guo 20
10. Zhang Wuji 20


GU LONG TOP 10

1. Xiao Yao Hou 21+
2. Dong Guo Xian Sheng 20
3. Shen Lang 20
4. Water Matriarch 20
5. Yu Pei Yu 20
6. Xie Xiao Feng 20
7. Ding Peng 20
8. Old Man Gong 20
9. Yan 13 20
10. Yan Nantian 20

[IcyFox]

JIN YONG TOP 10

1. Sweeper Monk 20
2. Xiao Yao Elders 20
3. Shi PoTian 20
4. Dugu Qiubai 20
5. Xu Zhu 20
6. Wang Chong Yang 20
7. Huang shang 20
8. Guo Jing 20
9. Yang Guo 21+
10. Zhang Wuji 20


GU LONG TOP 10

1. Xiao Yao Hou 21
2. Dong Guo Xian Sheng 20
3. Shen Lang 20
4. Water Matriarch 20
5. Yu Pei Yu 20
6. Xie Xiao Feng 20
7. Ding Peng 20
8. Old Man Gong 20
9. Yan 13 20
10. Yan Nantian 20

[blueberry]

JIN YONG TOP 10

1. Sweeper Monk 20
2. Xiao Yao Elders 20
3. Shi PoTian 20
4. Dugu Qiubai 20
5. Xu Zhu 20
6. Wang Chong Yang 20
7. Huang shang 20
8. Guo Jing 21+
9. Yang Guo 21
10. Zhang Wuji 20


GU LONG TOP 10

1. Xiao Yao Hou 21
2. Dong Guo Xian Sheng 20
3. Shen Lang 20
4. Water Matriarch 20
5. Yu Pei Yu 20
6. Xie Xiao Feng 20
7. Ding Peng 20
8. Old Man Gong 20
9. Yan 13 20
10. Yan Nantian 20

[Swordwiz]

JIN YONG TOP 10

1. Sweeper Monk 21+
2. Xiao Yao Elders 20
3. Shi PoTian 20
4. Dugu Qiubai 20
5. Xu Zhu 20
6. Wang Chong Yang 20
7. Huang shang 20
8. Guo Jing 21
9. Yang Guo 21
10. Zhang Wuji 20


GU LONG TOP 10

1. Xiao Yao Hou 21
2. Dong Guo Xian Sheng 20
3. Shen Lang 20
4. Water Matriarch 20
5. Yu Pei Yu 20
6. Xie Xiao Feng 20
7. Ding Peng 20
8. Old Man Gong 20
9. Yan 13 20
10. Yan Nantian 20

[WooWoo]

JIN YONG TOP 10

1. Sweeper Monk 20
2. Xiao Yao Elders 20
3. Shi PoTian 20
4. Dugu Qiubai 20
5. Xu Zhu 20
6. Wang Chong Yang 20
7. Huang shang 20
8. Guo Jing 21+
9. Yang Guo 21
10. Zhang Wuji 20


GU LONG TOP 10

1. Xiao Yao Hou 21
2. Dong Guo Xian Sheng 20
3. Shen Lang 20
4. Water Matriarch 20
5. Yu Pei Yu 21+
6. Xie Xiao Feng 20
7. Ding Peng 20
8. Old Man Gong 20
9. Yan 13 20
10. Yan Nantian 20

[chickenfeet]

Rules of the game :

1) You must pick side, either Jin Yong or Gu Long
2) Once you add a character for one group, you must always add a character for that group exclusively by 1+, and always subtract a character the opposite group by 1-
3) You DO NOT have to alternate your vote at this point
3) Five Rotation rule applies here so you must wait until 4 votes are casted after your last vote before you can vote again.

4) All characters will start from 20, you have two ways to kill a character :

a. By deducting his score to zero (this is going to be an advantage for your group because your opponent will have less a character)

otherwise...

b. One character with the lowest score from each team must be retired in a 24 hour

[chickenfeet]

JIN YONG TOP 10

1. Sweeper Monk 20
2. Xiao Yao Elders 20
3. Shi PoTian 20
4. Dugu Qiubai 20
5. Xu Zhu 20
6. Wang Chong Yang 20
7. Huang shang 20
8. Guo Jing 21+
9. Yang Guo 21
10. Zhang Wuji 20


GU LONG TOP 10

1. Xiao Yao Hou 22+
2. Dong Guo Xian Sheng 20
3. Shen Lang 20
4. Water Matriarch 20
5. Yu Pei Yu 21+
6. Xie Xiao Feng 20
7. Ding Peng 20
8. Old Man Gong 20
9. Yan 13 20
10. Yan Nantian 20

[IcyFox]

JIN YONG TOP 10

1. Sweeper Monk 20
2. Xiao Yao Elders 20
3. Shi PoTian 20
4. Dugu Qiubai 20
5. Xu Zhu 20
6. Wang Chong Yang 20
7. Huang shang 20
8. Guo Jing 21
9. Yang Guo 21
10. Zhang Wuji 20


GU LONG TOP 10

1. Xiao Yao Hou 21-
2. Dong Guo Xian Sheng 20
3. Shen Lang 20
4. Water Matriarch 20
5. Yu Pei Yu 21
6. Xie Xiao Feng 20
7. Ding Peng 20
8. Old Man Gong 20
9. Yan 13 20
10. Yan Nantian 20

[chickenfeet]

Icyfox, you're attacking Gu Long's team already ?

[kidd]

1 question. Must I alternate between 2 groups when voting?

I mean, can I just vote for the group I choose all the time and not substract people from the other group, or I have to substract from the other group after I voted for my group?

[chickenfeet]

1 question. Must I alternate between 2 groups when voting?

I mean, can I just vote for the group I choose all the time and not substract people from the other group, or I have to substract from the other group after I voted for my group?

The rule says you need not to alternate vote at this point, meaning you can only vote (add) for your group all the time (at least for now). It's a game of strategy, you should ask some of your group supporters to attack while some can fortify the group by building up votes, that's where to the fun is. know when to attack and know when to defend your group.

[Noisulli]

JIN YONG TOP 10

1. Sweeper Monk 20
2. Xiao Yao Elders 20
3. Shi PoTian 20
4. Dugu Qiubai 20
5. Xu Zhu 20
6. Wang Chong Yang 20
7. Huang shang 20
8. Guo Jing 21
9. Yang Guo 21
10. Zhang Wuji 20


GU LONG TOP 10

1. Xiao Yao Hou 20-
2. Dong Guo Xian Sheng 20
3. Shen Lang 20
4. Water Matriarch 20
5. Yu Pei Yu 21
6. Xie Xiao Feng 20
7. Ding Peng 20
8. Old Man Gong 20
9. Yan 13 20
10. Yan Nantian 20

[blueberry]

JIN YONG TOP 10

1. Sweeper Monk 20
2. Xiao Yao Elders 20
3. Shi PoTian 20
4. Dugu Qiubai 20
5. Xu Zhu 20
6. Wang Chong Yang 20
7. Huang shang 20
8. Guo Jing 21
9. Yang Guo 21
10. Zhang Wuji 21+


GU LONG TOP 10

1. Xiao Yao Hou 20
2. Dong Guo Xian Sheng 20
3. Shen Lang 20
4. Water Matriarch 20
5. Yu Pei Yu 21
6. Xie Xiao Feng 20
7. Ding Peng 20
8. Old Man Gong 20
9. Yan 13 20
10. Yan Nantian 20