I must be really crazy, but I spent my time reading through 91 pages of this thread. talk about crazy
Reading through everyone's opinions, and having seen the series now, it makes me too want to write a review- I think I will when I get the chance. But I thoroughly enjoyed the debates and thoughts of a lot of the posters here, such as always, sunnysnow. And not only do I love
saranghaeyo's and
drymonkey's reviews about the series (because I agreed with them about 95% of the time, and they were spot on to what I thought too), but also your opinion and analysis of the series. To mention,
aicof's and
NuDaFu's posts were great reads too! I know there were many more, so thank you for such great analysis and debates

I am totallyyyy late, I know.
As a fan of the novel, and the 80's version, (I've watched allllll the remakes too, because it's my absolute favorite wuxia story) I must be one of the few minorities to really like this version.
Initially, I was extremely unhappy about some of the changes made, but loved the arcs of character development they did in here. I'm more than happy with how they built on Guo Jing's and Huang Rong's love story. (I think in terms of the couple, Hu Ge and Ariel really nailed it for me) I was also one of the first to put her down- finding her not fit for the role because of her physique, (though I am a huge fan of hers, and probably even more so after this) However, she won me over completely with her portrayal of Huang Rong, and I have to agree, she's probably the closest to the novel. I felt like she breathed life into the HR from the novel. She just nailed it! I was blown away, and to me, Ariel may have edged out Barbara as a Huang Rong with all the depth of emotions to it by a bit.
As for Hu Ge's portrayal of GJ, I was one to doubt he could pull it off as well- considering he came off really smart looking to me. But I was really pleased with is performance here, and will probably reserve my analysis on it for when I get a chance to write a review.
So considering my prior thoughts, I had to eat my words after finishing the series.
Of course there are several things I didn't like about this series when I first saw it. I just somewhat skimmed through it, because of how bias I was with loving the 80's version with Felix and Barbara. It's funny though, because I wasn't a hugeeeeee fan of Felix as Guo Jing in there, but the series was the best of all the versions I had seen up to 2003.
Then just recently, a friend asked me to recommend a good Chinese wuxia series to watch, and since he had never seen any of Jin Yong's work nor had any knowledge to the wuxia genre, I thought, w
hy not tell him to watch LOCH. I suggested the 80's version, since it's a golden classic, but he felt it would be too old school for him, and so I don't know why, but between 2003 and 2008, I told him to watch 2008.
After starting it, my friend ended up really addicted to it. He started talking to me about it, and I was somewhat lost, considering I skimmed through it really fast the first time. So I actually found myself revisiting it. And the second time around, I have to say, I love it!
I finished it, and at the end, I couldn't, for the longest time, decide which version between my old love of the 80's and this 08 version. Deep down though, I might have to say that 08 may have edged out a bit, mainly for character development, and their relationships.
The Greats did a really nice job in my opinion. I found Brian's Qi Gong awesome, and I'm glad he replaced the previous actor. I don't think I would've liked it any other way. Of course it falls short next to Lau Dan's Qi Gong- because I found his interaction wonderful with Huang Rong. It really showed his love to her as a student and what not. In this version, there was only a slight bit of it, and more so that he passed on the leadership of being the Chief when he thought he was going to die. I wanted more QiGong and Huang Rong interaction, because in ROCH it still transcends on how much he adores HR and how much she really loves her sifu.
I too liked Anthony's portrayal of HYS, but it also was a bit more calm compared to the aloof ways of Kenneth who really owns at being HYS. Btu Anthony did a fine job with his expression and he managed to show the love he has for his wife and his daughter very well.
Yideng was alright for me, because he only had a short part anyways, but I might be one of the few who liked the actor playing him.

He looked way cooler as a monk than as the emperor. It was like two different people for me!
OYF...I don't know what to say. He didn't leave any impression on me at all, and really can't beat the 80's OYF.
Despite many shortcomings, I really loved this remake of all the ones from 94, 03, and now this. Personally, I think it was the pure love GJ and HR had in this version that won me over completely. You could just tell they love each other, compared to even the 80's version. I felt moved and teary eyed and could really feel how much they cherished each other. And you can see their growth from the beginning of the series to at last, the very end.
I'm so glad I went back to revisit it, and will try to save more of my thoughts for later.
...I didn't realize I wrote an essay >.<

sorry.
and
I have a request: it is soooo hard to track the soundtrack from this series, but I LOVEEEEEEED the instrumental backgrounds used in this version.
Does anyone have access to the OST, or did LOCH even release an OST aside from the three songs.