Best ROCH Characters in all ROCH Versions

[Surferket]

XLN - LYF ROCH06
YG - Andy Lau/Idy
HR - Andy Lau/Idy
GJ - Andy Lau/Idy
LMC - ROCH06
GF - ROCH06 (CSS was really *****y all the time and like perpetually in PMS)
GX - ROCH06
Gong Sun Lu Er - Andy/Idy
Old Man Gong Sun - ROCH06 (Kenny Bee really ROXXER as the ultimate DOM)
GLGS (Flying Wheels) - ROCH06
Wu Bros - Andy/Idy (they were really lame dogs following GF around)
LWS and cousin - Andy/Idy

[strife_au]

XLN - LYF ROCH06
YG - Andy Lau/Idy
HR - Andy Lau/Idy
GJ - Andy Lau/Idy
LMC - ROCH06
GF - ROCH06 (CSS was really *****y all the time and like perpetually in PMS)
GX - ROCH06
Gong Sun Lu Er - Andy/Idy
Old Man Gong Sun - ROCH06 (Kenny Bee really ROXXER as the ultimate DOM)
GLGS (Flying Wheels) - ROCH06
Wu Bros - Andy/Idy (they were really lame dogs following GF around)
LWS and cousin - Andy/Idy

XLN - Carmen Lee ROCH 95
YG - Louis Koo ROCH 95
LMC - ROCH 06
GF - ROCH 06
GX - ROCH 95/06 both excellent
GSLE - ROCH 83
Old Man Gong Sun - ROCH06
Wu brothers - ROCH 95
LWS and CY - ROCH 95
GJ - ROCH06
HR - ROCH95
ZBT - ROCH06
JLFW - ROCH06

[0-0-0]

XLN- Idy 83
YG- Louis Koo 95
LMC- 06
GF- 06
GX- 06
GSLE- 06
CY- Maggie Cheung!!! 95, no competition there
HR- 83
WYP- 06
GJ- 83

[algaechu]

I like most of the characters in ROCH06 (especially XLN) more than other versions except Chen Ying. This character in ROCH95 is better.

[Sugar]

XLN - LYF ROCH06
YG - Andy Lau/Idy
HR - Andy Lau/Idy
GJ - Andy Lau/Idy
LMC - ROCH06
GF - ROCH06 (CSS was really *****y all the time and like perpetually in PMS)
GX - ROCH06
Gong Sun Lu Er - Andy/Idy
Old Man Gong Sun - ROCH06 (Kenny Bee really ROXXER as the ultimate DOM)
GLGS (Flying Wheels) - ROCH06
Wu Bros - Andy/Idy (they were really lame dogs following GF around)
LWS and cousin - Andy/Idy

YG- Andy
XLN- Idy
GJ- 83
HR- 83,au yeung pang still the best so far
GF-ROCH 06
LMC- 83/06.. tie
GX ROCH 06
GSLE-TCS singapore
Oldman GS- ROCH 06
GLGS- of 83/06
LWS-83
CY- 95

[Li Nhi]

YG - Andy Lau (kid stage), Huang Xiao Ming (Condor Hero stage)
XLN - Crystal Liu; she is truly like an angel
HR- ROCH 83 DEFINITELY
GJ- ROCH 83 DEFINITELY
LMC- ROCH 06; she was really awesome
GF- ROCH 06; liked her from beginning to end
GX- ROCH 06; she is literally the BEST GX there is out there
GSL'r- ROCH 06; I actually cried when she died
GSZ- ROCH 06 KENNY BEE; he has never disappointed me in any role
GWM- ROCH 06; so what if the character's suppose to be skinny/scrawny? This guy was kick a$$, and I kind of pitied his death in the end
Wu Bros- ROCH 83, ugly...but they match the roles perfectly
LWS- ROCH 83; I would've said 06 if the producers didn't delete so many of her scenes which made the series unmemorable
CY- ROCH 95
HYB- ROCH 06, as I've said in her thread, she is very pretty and talented
YLQ- ROCH 06. One word: hot
HD- ROCH 83, come on. It's Kent Tong! Nobody's HD could beat his
TZP- ROCH 06, wow, He's actually kinda cute. I could clearly see how obsessed he is with XLN, and the rape scene was done very well.
Condor- ROCH 83, ok. So it was crappy, but ROCH 06 just cracked me up. ROCH 95 was unmemorable

[crazylife123]

YG - Andy(Young YG), HXM (Older YG, he looked bad@ss!)
XLN - LYF; tied with Idy in acting but LYF has the looks/martial art skills
HR- '83; she was perfect.
GJ- '83/'06
LMC- '06; best looking one and portray her character very well.
GF- '83/'06
GX- '98/'06
GSL'r- '06; she makes the color green look good. LOL
GSZ- '06; always a good actor.
GWM- '83/'06
Wu Bros- '83
LWS- '06; she played her part well. really cute.
CY- can't remember the past ones. didnt like the '06 as much.
HYB- '06
YLQ- '06; he's bad@ss! he will get more leads.
HD- '06; he may look and sound gay but he's like one of those anime villians
TZP- '06; he played his part very well. many people wants to kick his @ss!
Condor- '83; still have a clear picture of the bird in my head after 10 years.

[mawguy]

XLN - LYF
YG - HXM
HR - AYPS ROCH83
GJ - LKY ROCH83
LMC - LYW ROCH83
GF - none
GX - ROCH06
Gong Sun Lu Er - ROCH06
Old Man Gong Sun - ROCH83
GLGS (Flying Wheels) - ROCH83
Wu Bros - no opinion
LWS and cousin - ROCH83

5 Greats:
East - ROCH83
West - no opinion
North - ROCH83
South - none (i would have cast Kong Hon)
Central - ROCH83

Misc.:
HD - ROCH83
YLQ - ROCH83

[Thai guy]

XLN - Idy Chan
YG - Andy Lau
HR - Who else can beat Au Yeung Pui San???-ROCH 83
GJ - LKY ROCH83 (YES!!!)
LMC - LYW ROCH 83 (YES!!!)
GF - ROCH 95 (although the one in ROCH 83 was not bad at all)
GX - ROCH 95
Gong Sun Lu Er - ROCH 83
Old Man Gong Sun - ROCH 95
GLGS (Flying Wheels) - ROCH83
Wu Bros - ROCH 83
LWS and cousin - ROCH 83

Yelu Qi- Simon Yam - ROCH 83
Huo Do- Kent Tong - ROCH 83
Zhou Bo Tong- Chun Wong- ROCH 83
Huang Yaoshi-Kennet Tsang- ROCH 83
H7G- Lau Dan-ROCH 83/95

[yu feng]

YG - definitely HXM
XLN - definitely LYF
GJ - ROCH 06
HR - ROCH 06
GF - ROCH 06 (so much gorgeous)
GX - ROCH 06 (so much cute)
LMC - ROCH 06 (so sexy)
JLGS - ROCH 95
GSLE - ROCH 06 (beautiful)
GSZ - ROCH 06
CY - ROCH 95
LWS - ROCH 83
Huo Du - ROCH 83

Zhou Botong - ROCH 06
Huang Yaoshi - ROCH 06
Ouyang Feng - ROCH 95
Yideng Dashi - ROCH 95
Hong Qigong - ROCH 95

Zhao Zijing - ROCH 06
Zhen Zhibing / Yin Zhiping - ROCH 06

[luvleila]

YG - definitely HXM
XLN - definitely LYF
GJ - ROCH 06
HR - ROCH 06
GF - ROCH 06 (so much gorgeous)
GX - ROCH 06 (so much cute)
LMC - ROCH 06 (so sexy)
JLGS - ROCH 95
GSLE - ROCH 06 (beautiful)
GSZ - ROCH 06
CY - ROCH 95
LWS - ROCH 83
Huo Du - ROCH 83

Zhou Botong - ROCH 06
Huang Yaoshi - ROCH 06
Ouyang Feng - ROCH 95
Yideng Dashi - ROCH 95
Hong Qigong - ROCH 95

Zhao Zijing - ROCH 06
Zhen Zhibing / Yin Zhiping - ROCH 06

my nominees are exactly the same as u. couldn't agree less on lyf and hxm being yg and xln. gf and gx are not bad as well. well, great minds think alike

[strife_au]

my nominees are exactly the same as u. couldn't agree less on lyf and hxm being yg and xln. gf and gx are not bad as well. well, great minds think alike

lol great minds think a like more like idolised minds think along the same dusty road

[Demonic Swordsman]

are the old version even worth watching?

the special effects and quality wont be as good right?

[strife_au]

ROCH95 was splendid... way more enjoyable to watch than ROCH06

[crazylife123]

ROCH95 was splendid... way more enjoyable to watch than ROCH06

i dont know about that. tried watching it but got bored quick. the fight scene suck like hell. worst than '83.

[Sugar]

are the old version even worth watching?

the special effects and quality wont be as good right?

It depends. I think each adaption had its own charm. If you want "prettier" fighting than ROCH 06. You want more classical fighting, 83.

Some special effects in ROCH 06 were cheesy..so yeah

[kenixgoh]

XLN - Roch 06 (well, LYF's portrayal is the most faithful to novel among other actresses)
YG - Roch 95 (Louis did a fantastic job, 1/2 evil / good, like the novel)
HR - Roch 83 (Ouyang PeiShan... )
GJ - Roch 93 (Bryan Leung's GJ is the best!)
LMC - Roch 83 (dunno her name but she was great)
GF - Roch 06 (CZH's GF is sweet)
GX - Roch 06 (Ahh... YM is so cute but her scenes were short)
Gong Sun Lu Er - Roch 06 (pretty)
Old Man Gong Sun - Roch 06 (Kenny Bee)
GLGS (Flying Wheels) - Roch 83 (That actor left deep impression in my mind..lol)
Wu Bros - No idea (Never bother about them.. haha)
LWS and cousin - Roch 83 (decent acting)

[crazylife123]

are the old version even worth watching?

the special effects and quality wont be as good right?

If ROCH '06 was your first ROCH series, then the previous adaptations will look crappy for you. Bad move if you want to watch the previous series. You should watch the previous series first then this series afterward. I've tried it and all I did was laugh. It's just isn't the same anymore.

[Sugar]

If ROCH '06 was your first ROCH series, then the previous adaptations will look crappy for you. Bad move if you want to watch the previous series. You should watch the previous series first then this series afterward. I've tried it and all I did was laugh. It's just isn't the same anymore.

again, solely on biased opinions

SOme people watched the older ones and ROCH 06 and still believed it is crappy .

[strife_au]

again, solely on biased opinions

SOme people watched the older ones and ROCH 06 and still believed it is crappy .

affirmative