It's something that I been wondering for a while now. How many of The Johnnys pop idol singer will make it pass Simon if they audition for American Idol. (Please put the fact that their japanese and that their already professional singer aside, if you must pretent that it jpop verson of Idol)

The first person that comes to mind in not making it pass Simon is Nakai from SMAP, and the person who might win the title is Ohno from Arashi. I'm a fan of both group, and I not here to start a fight (I know the topic can be a sensitive to some fans.) I just want to know other fan and non fan opinion.