wow Jin Yong1, im impressed....bravo for the effort, man....i havent watched 95 but the pictures you posted are enough to say Carman Lee is the most believable XLN...
Da One and Only,
Idols: Mark Dacascos and Vicki Zhao Wei
Fav Artists: Zhang Tie Lin, Cheng E Kin, Vin Diesel, Jet Li, Amy Chan Sau Man, Michelle Rodriguez, Theresa Lee Yee Hong
Fav Series: The Great General, Heroine of The Yangs, Huan Zhu Ge Ge I & II, Secret Battle of The Majesties
Fav Movies: The Matrix I, G.I Jane, Fist of Legend, Drive, Gladiator, 2009 Lost Memories, So Close, Crying Freeman
My name is Maximus Decimus Meridius; Commander of the Army of the North, General of the Felix Legions, loyal servant to the true emperor; Marcus Aurilius. Father to a murdered son, husband to a murdered wife, and I will have my vengeance, in this life or the next.
- The Spaniard -
in fact you're right ghostdarTeal'c, there is a hong kong article reported Jin Yong stated himself that "Carman made XLN believable."Originally Posted by ghostdarTeal'c
GREAT picture JIn Yong 1.... I almost forget ROCH 95's scenes........ those are NICE....... I love them so much both 95 and 06
WOA!!!!........ nice pixs Jin Yong man, bravo for the work. Out of all each parts comparisions Carman's version stood out the most.
I think Jacqueline Wu stood out the most among the rest for the wrong reason: she was the only one wearing black.
I like three of them( Idy/Carmen/LYF ). Idy Chan is the first XLN I watched in series and at that time I really like her playing XLN, she acted very well ( good couple with Andy )
Carmen Lee maybe has the closest "look" and caracther to XLN ( the face, the age, etc ), and Liu Yi Fei actually is the most beautifull XLN ever. Actually I think she has the best fighting scene compares with the other two.
The only thing that I found her not suitable enough to play XLN is the fact that she's too young being couple with HXM ( he's very mature as YG, I love him though ) where her face is a babyish one also. Maybe if she's around 25 while playing XLN, I'm sure they will make them the best couple of YG n XLN
To be honest, I actually don't like this technique of XLN and YG in this pic. at all. It ruin the pure love between them.
so many pix.....cool
anyway, ROCH 95 is good b/c Carmen help it....Louis didn't do JACK...his acting suck
ROCH 06 is good b/c of the effect and LYF....everything is better.....LYF actin better than HXM...just like ROCH 95....the actress is better than the actor
ROCH 98 is great b/c both actor did a great job....must b/c they like each other at tat time o soemthing......
ROCH 83...too old to watch it b/c watching the newer one would make this one suck......
Originally Posted by perfectrose
actually, i feel you got it twisted - i feel that liu yi fei have the closest look to XLN whereas carman is the most beautiful XLN. liu yi fei is suppose to look young because her character is only 16 years old. it's huang xiao ming that looks too old.
carman potrayed a cold XLN whereas liu yi fei did an emotional XLN.
so i think it's correct that liu yi fei is better when potraying XLN looks but carman is better with XLN inner character if we're comparing them to XLN in the novel.
Solitary trees, if they grow at all, grow strong.
Honestly, i think carman potrayed a cold XLN whereas liu yi fei did an emotional XLN. i believe carman performed XLN is closest to the novel, she had better charisma and acting.
correction, carman was closest to the 1st/2nd edition but lyf was closest to 3rd editionOriginally Posted by darknight123
yea that's what i meant, carman was closest to the 1st/2nd edition for her icy-cold xln which gives me a goose-bump when her 1st appeared and lyf was closest to 3rd edition for her emotions xln, not to mentioned fann wong's xln, hers is quite emotions too.Originally Posted by crazylife123
Last edited by darknight123; 12-07-06 at 02:39 AM.
i still think ROCH06 is the best and liu yi fei is the best xln ever, most beautiful one too
although lyf did quite a good job as young and emotional xln but hers is toooo fancy for a girl who live under the cave for 18+ yrs., carman protrayed xln the closest to the novel she's just simple and beautiful
Originally Posted by darknight123
what do you mean too fancy?