Comparing Ding Pang's Curved Sabre and Dook Goo Kau Bai/Yeung Gor's Heavy Iron Sword

[Ken Cheng]

Both Ding Pang's Curved Sabre and Dook Goo Kau Bai/Yeung Gor's Heavy Iron Sword were known for being extraordinary marital arts training tools and nearly unbeatable weapons in combat. How do these two weapons compare to one another as both training tools and as actual combat instruments? Which is the superior of the two?

[kyss of the sword]

i'm going with DGKB's heavy sword, eventually, you discard the sword and become more powerful, ding ping was way weaker without his sabre.

[Ken Cheng]

i'm going with DGKB's heavy sword, eventually, you discard the sword and become more powerful, ding ping was way weaker without his sabre.

I'm not sure that was true anymore by the end of his story. His enemy Lau Yerk Chung, armed with the Curved Sabre, attacked an unarmed Ding Pang and Ding *still* beat him.

[CC]

i'm going with DGKB's heavy sword, eventually, you discard the sword and become more powerful, ding ping was way weaker without his sabre.

DP did use a wooden sabre and sliced his opponent with the real one.

[Ardor]

What are the chemical elements that make up the two?

[strife_au]

Curved sabre is better

[Yeung Gor]

What are the chemical elements that make up the two?

the curved sabre is made of refined steel, while the Heavy Iron Sword is made of a special iron material call Adamantium.

[JamesG]

It was sort of hinted that the Heavy Iron Sword might be made from a meteorite. That would give it some nickel content.

[Trien Chieu]

Both Ding Pang's Curved Sabre and Dook Goo Kau Bai/Yeung Gor's Heavy Iron Sword were known for being extraordinary marital arts training tools and nearly unbeatable weapons in combat. How do these two weapons compare to one another as both training tools and as actual combat instruments? Which is the superior of the two?

If both fighters are both equally good without weapon then the one with HIS would beat the one with the CS.

I'm not sure that was true anymore by the end of his story. His enemy Lau Yerk Chung, armed with the Curved Sabre, attacked an unarmed Ding Pang and Ding *still* beat him.

Weak fighter like Lau Yerk Chung doesn't count.