could XYS and MRB been modest to XF

[soulmelody]

actually when XYS fought with XF,could he had been fighting at not his best, so as not to injure his son,make him lose face and the most importantly to test where he stands? And when at shaolin temple, when MRB praised XF,could he had actually been better then XF because hes equalled with XYS. I think he also praised XF to help his son retain the pride of North QF and South MRF
I think they could be ranked like this:


XF:100%
JMZ:105%
MRF:45%
XYS:125%
MRB:135%

[yittz]

So many assumptions...

Anyway XF thought he improved signicantly between excised as beggar leader and later when he went up north.

[Whsie]

I don't think that logic works out there. As CC and I showed, there were mutiple instances where it is showned that JMZ~XF~XYS~MRB that your estimated logic can be neglected. We only use logic when there isn't actual evidence to back it up.

[kyss of the sword]

XYS was better then XF's teachers, the monk and the begger's leader. but XF with his natural talent and both of their teachings reached the same level as his father. JMZ was the best is proficienticy of moves and the best in inner power slighlty. XYS amd MRB were equal in all aspects.

[hyoyatika]

actually when XYS fought with XF,could he had been fighting at not his best, so as not to injure his son,make him lose face and the most importantly to test where he stands? And when at shaolin temple, when MRB praised XF,could he had actually been better then XF because hes equalled with XYS. I think he also praised XF to help his son retain the pride of North QF and South MRF
I think they could be ranked like this:


XF:100%
JMZ:105%
MRF:45%
XYS:125%
MRB:135%

Very interesting train of thought, could be possible, but I'm curious-why do you rate MRB above XYS?

[PJ]

There are multiple signs that XF is slightly better than MRB. We also know XYS > XF in whip technique, but I don't think that helps much in barehanded combat.

[CC]

There are multiple signs that XF is slightly better than MRB. We also know XYS > XF in whip technique, but I don't think that helps much in barehanded combat.

You know, we always rate young MRB real high because as a young teen he could one-shot Yellow Eyebrow. Using that yardstick, young XYS was even scarier then MRB because in their first encounter, MRB was frightened by XYS's ability.

[hyoyatika]

actually when XYS fought with XF,could he had been fighting at not his best, so as not to injure his son,make him lose face and the most importantly to test where he stands? And when at shaolin temple, when MRB praised XF,could he had actually been better then XF because hes equalled with XYS. I think he also praised XF to help his son retain the pride of North QF and South MRF
I think they could be ranked like this:


XF:100%
JMZ:105%
MRF:45%
XYS:125%
MRB:135%

I don't have any issues with such a theory; but why do you rate MRB higher than XYS?