Warning: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in ..../includes/class_bbcode.php on line 2958
Review: Jin Fen Shi Jia ( 金粉世家/The Story of a Noble Family) 2003--Mainland China
Results 1 to 3 of 3

Thread: Review: Jin Fen Shi Jia ( 金粉世家/The Story of a Noble Family) 2003--Mainland China

  1. #1
    Senior Member redfirefly124's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    1,021

    Default Review: Jin Fen Shi Jia ( 金粉世家/The Story of a Noble Family) 2003--Mainland China

    Okay, I posted this on the main site on April 9th, 2007...but it hasn't been edited yet....is this normal? Anyways, I suspected it wasn't, so I decided to post it here. Enjoy.


    Jin Fen Shi Jia
    aka Story of a Noble Family/ Yesterdayís Glitter


    Genre: 1900s tragic family story

    Main Cast
    Chen Kun...........Jin Yan Xi
    Dong Jie............Leng Qing Qiu
    Liu Yi Fei............Bai Xiu Zhu

    This was my first drama, so Iíve decided to write my first review on it! But I DID NOT completely watch it, to tell you the truth, since I got a bit obessed with Dae Jang Geum....but I only missed a few episodes, maybe something like episodes 33-38.
    *WARNING! Spoilers!
    **I try to be picky and mark hardly. My rating scale:
    1-Horrible.
    2-Pretty bad.
    3-Adequate; marginal.
    4-Pretty good.
    5-Amazing.

    Plot-3/5
    I wouldnít know if it followed the novel by Zhang Heng Shui or not, but the plot was okay. It was a bit draggy sometimes, like when they had these huge please-can-I-borrow-money issues. Those were just annoying and boring. Anyways, my favorite scene had to be when Leng Qing Qiu poured the bucket of water on Jin Yan Xi. That was kinda funny, cause I HATED Jin Yan Xi!

    Cast-3.75/5
    Generally good cast. In detail:

    Chen Kun-Jin Yan Xi-8/10-A good performance overall.

    Facial Expressions-1.5/2-I think he did a good job with the facial expressions! Especially when he was flirting with Leng Qing Qiu, lol! And his but-Iím-innocent face was good too! But sometimes his face was still rather neutral, with no apparent expression.
    Body Movement-1.25/2-Chen Kunís body language was pretty good too, especially when he was with Leng Qing Qiu. But it wasn't anything particularly awesome, so I give him 1.25/2.
    Voice-1.5/2-Chen Kun's voice was okay, but nothing special. It had adequate emotion and stuff, and it didn't particularly grab my attention.
    Chemistry-1.75/2-Chen Kun has excellent chemistry with all the actors and actresses in Jin Fen Shi Jia! His relationship with Leng Qing Qiu and Bai Xiu Zhu was very nicely done, but I have to say he had the funniest relationship with his servant Jin Rong!
    Look-2/2-Personally I think Chen Kun has the perfect look for a spoiled son who lavishly spends money!

    Dong Jie-Leng Qing Qiu-8.5/10-She was the best out of the 3 main leads! ^^

    Facial Expressions-1.5/2-She was awesome! Especially with her cold expressions toward Jin Yan Xi at first! But like Chen Kun, her face sometimes had a rather neutral look, with no apparent expression.
    Body Movement-1.25/2-Pretty good, but nothing particularly special, so 1.25/2.
    Voice-2/2-Awesome! Perfect voice for a smart brainy girl! Plus, she had the coldness in her voice toward Jin Yan Xi, and the kind of sad, helpless voice towards the end!
    Chemistry-1.75/2-Very good! We could tell she started to liked Jin Yan Xi, but was also kind of attached to her teacher....and her love towards her mother was very touching!
    Look-2/2-Dong Jie does have the scholar girl look down! And she fits the description of "very beautiful" by Jin Yan Xi, especially in the beginning and the end. ^^

    Liu Yi Fei-Bai Xiu Zhu-7.5/10-A good performance for a beginner.

    Facial Expressions-1.25/2-Good. I loved her snotty look, and her condescending-ness towards Leng Qing Qiu. She did pretty good in this area. However, her face was kinda blank sometimes, like she didn't know what to do with it. But that might of been because this was her first series...?
    Body Movement-1.5/2-Pretty good, but again nothing particularly special, so 1.5/2.
    Voice-1/2-It was okay, I guess, but not particularly good, and plus, kinda annoying at times.
    Chemistry-1.75/2-I thought it was good. You could see her relationship with her sister-in-law, brother, and Jin Yan Xi very clearly. Oh, and her cousin, the third wife in the Jin family as well!
    Look-2/2-Liu Yi Fei definitely has the "Da Xiao Jie" look.
    *Side Note: When I saw this I had NO CLUE who LYF was, so my opinion is pretty neutral. Also, I just wanted to say that I think she did EXCELLENT when she had to reject Jin Yan Xi's proposal.

    Other Cast
    The rest of the cast did a pretty good job as well. In particular:
    -Leng Qing Qiu's mom
    -Leng Qing Qiu's servant lady
    -Jin Rong, Jin Yan Xi's servant
    .....did very very well. Special mention to Shu Chang, who played the eighth sister in the Jin family! (I think her name was Mei Li?) She was my fav out of all the cast, and her character was also my favorite! ^^

    Music-3.5/5
    The tunes were fairly catchy and nice. I especially liked the ending theme. The beginning theme was nice as well. All the music in between was rather nice, but after awhile it got a bit annoying and repetitive.

    Scenery-3/5
    It was okay. The main house was very grand and spectacular. The dandelion field was also very nice. But it didn't totally catch my eyes, or make me go, "WOW!"

    Costumes-4.25/5
    Very appropriate to the era. I especially liked Leng Qing Qiu's schoolgirl outfit. Bai Xiu Zhu's hair and outfits had a sort of "Da Xiao Jie" air, which was good. Very appropriate and nice overall.

    Atmosphere/Feeling-3.75/5
    This didn't really have a particular feel to it for me. BUT, it did seem like a sort of 1900s time period, which was good.

    Overall-3.5/5
    So...to watch or not to watch? Well, it all depends on your personal interests. I felt it dragged a bit sometimes, but overall it was a very nicely done tragic family tale. Quite depressing in the end, actually, but I won't ruin it for you. But a pretty average drama compared to some of the others I've seen. So this isn't a MUST-WATCH, but a pretty good drama overall. I'd watch it if you have nothing else left that you want to watch.

    ~red
    hu ge, yang mi, yuan hong, liu shishi.
    wang luodan, li guangjie.

  2. #2
    Senior Member lilviet_grl8o8's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Hawaii, USA
    Posts
    590

    Default

    oh wow chen kun is hotttt!! (; loved him with a-baw in the goldenwarrior& princess
    Always in search of great historical/costume dramas.
    Find me on MyDramaList ^_^

  3. #3
    Administrator spcnet's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2003
    Posts
    2,933

    Default

    This review is finally published at http://www.spcnet.tv/Chinese-TV-Seri...iew-r1494.html. Sorry it took so long, our editorial queue was backed up and now we're clearing it out.
    -SC

Similar Threads

  1. The Silver Chambers of Sorrows 《銀樓金粉》
    By triumph2004 in forum TVB Series
    Replies: 34
    Last Post: 02-01-11, 09:25 AM
  2. New series: Xiang Fen Shi Jia
    By Thuy Tien in forum Mainland China TV Series
    Replies: 28
    Last Post: 04-19-10, 09:14 PM
  3. The Story of a Noble Family
    By shootingst8r in forum Mainland China TV Series
    Replies: 186
    Last Post: 01-22-08, 08:25 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •