Originally Posted by
Ian Liew
My ratings so far would read something like this..
FIRST TIER: Recommendable
Secret of the Linked Cities 2004
Sword Stained with Royal Blood 2006
Heaven Sword Dragon Sabre 2003
Demi Gods Semi Devils 2004
Yongzheng Dynasty
Smiling Proud Wanderer 2001
SECOND TIER: some parts ok, some parts blah
Romance of the 3 Kingdoms (blah is 100% attributable to cast changing mid-serial)
Legend of the Condor Heroes 2003
Return of the Condor Heroes 2006
Lu Xiao Feng (the one with Julian Cheung)
Book and Sword
Fei Dao You Jian Fei Dao
THIRD TIER: bearable, but don't count on anything
Chinese Paladin (I didn't get past the 1st few CDs, but I found Hu Ge's character quite unbearable. It probably gets better later).
Chang Jian Shang Si
Golden Sword
Xia Kexing
BLAH TIER: not recommendable, but not atrocious either
AVOID TIER: Waste of time
Amazing Story
I guess I've just been lucky with what I've picked so far.... apart from Amazing Story.