Was Seung Gwoon Sheut Yee really the liar everyone thought she was?

[Ken Cheng]

The girl Seung Gwoon Sheut Yee from the first LUK SIU FUNG story (THE GOLDEN ROC KINGDOM'S TREASURE) was known as a chronic liar. Was she really as big a liar as everybody thought she was, though? Everything she told Luk Siu Fung about her cousin, Princess Seung Gwoon Dan Fung, murdering Seung Gwoon Fei Yin was true from her point of view. The information was inaccurate, but that's because Fei Yin had misled Sheut Yee as well. Sheut Yee never told any lies concerning what she saw occurring at the Golden Roc King's household.

She did tell some minor fibs about being Luk Siu Fung's aunt and Fa Mun Lau's great-aunt (and that Fa was in his fifties), but other than these little white lies, she didn't seem to be a big liar.

[Suet Seung]

Whoa, this is a really rare Gu Long related thread coming from Ken. For as long as I could remember, Ken posts mostly about JY's novels.

[Ken Cheng]

Whoa, this is a really rare Gu Long related thread coming from Ken. For as long as I could remember, Ken posts mostly about JY's novels.

No, I post some Gu Long stuff...problem is nobody ever responds to the Gu Long questions.

Or, the response is invariably something like "Sai Mun Chui Sheut sucks and is really overrated!"

[PJ]

Or, the response is invariably something like "Sai Mun Chui Sheut sucks and is really overrated!"

Nah, just that he is far below the level achieved by Third Master Xie Xiaofeng and Yan 13

[Felix]

Nah, just that he is far below the level achieved by Third Master Xie Xiaofeng and Yan 13

Especially Yan 13 right, PJ?

[mawguy]

suet yee does tell a lot of lies, a lot of outrageous lies. i think it's a habit she picked-up. she's overshadowed by both her cousin and her sister, so this is probably her way of getting attention. of course, she suffers the tragedy of the boy who cried wolf: when she tells the truth, noone believes her.

ken cheng should post more GL comments.

[Ken Cheng]

suet yee does tell a lot of lies, a lot of outrageous lies. i think it's a habit she picked-up. she's overshadowed by both her cousin and her sister, so this is probably her way of getting attention. of course, she suffers the tragedy of the boy who cried wolf: when she tells the truth, noone believes her.

Ironically, however, Sheut Yee never lies about anything *important*. All of her lies are just the embellishments of an imaginative teenage girl (or was she a pre-teen?). When people's lives are at stake, she tells the truth.

I wonder what ever became of her. A number of the LUK SIU FUNG Book 1 surviving characters never showed up again.

ken cheng should post more GL comments.

If I do, will more of you guys respond to them?

[Will-]

If I do, will more of you guys respond to them?

Probably not. I am blind like Ke Zhen'e when it comes to GL.

[mawguy]

ken cheng should post more GL comments.

If I do, will more of you guys respond to them?

i promise i will.