Endless Love

[vivi_g]

I couldn't help it but start a thread about these two songs from the movie The Myth (2005). There's two version to Endless Love: one sung by Sun Nan and Han Hong & the other sung by Jackie Chan and Kim Hee Sun.
I just want to know which one do you guys think is better or like better and please explain why.

Here's the link to listen them on Youtube

Jackie Chan & Kim Hee Sun
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iu_YttoUWPI

Sun Nan & Han Hong
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NtdfU2nNfdI

I like the Sun Nan & Han Hong's version more, because it sounds more harmonious and pleasant. And of course because they are professional singers they sound way better.

*EDIT* PLEASE DON'T VOTE FOR BOTH! I MADE A MISTAKE.

[imthatlady]

OMG i love this song haha. i'm in my school's library now so i can't listen to the one sung by Sun Nan and Han Hong to judge but i will def. once i get home ;]

[skylee]

Sun Nan sounds 100x better than Jackie Chan, I think I like Han Hong's voice, too, but for this particular song, I prefer Kim Hee Sun. She sounds sweet and lovely when singing the parts in Korean. Her Chinese is kind of poor though. But you're right, the latter version sounds much more pleasant in terms of harmony and rhythm, due to the singers' voice compatibility and professionalism.

[Leanna]

i thought the korean version sounded better than the chinese (kim hee sun)
but jackie chans' singing was sorta bad... not as good as sun nan
ahah, id be perfect if sun nan and kim hee sun sang it..... ahah i guess both then, its like the awesomest songg ever

[LTD]

i thought the korean version sounded better than the chinese (kim hee sun)
but jackie chans' singing was sorta bad... not as good as sun nan
ahah, id be perfect if sun nan and kim hee sun sang it..... ahah i guess both then, its like the awesomest songg ever

I agree. I loved the sun nan's voice, but han hong just sounded like she was yelling through her parts. Sun Nan and Kim Hee Sun should just do a remake of the song, not to say that Jackie doesn't have talent, I just don't think that singing is one of his fortes anymore.

[Raenon]

Topic: "Which song fo you prefer?"

I thought Kee Hee Sun and Jackie Chan sounds better although I like Han Hong voice better.The song seem less sad with Han Hong singing ... ...

When I was looking at the poll results,I was actually thinking.What's the point and purpose of creating such a poll when you want to know the preference(the better of the two) and there you put a choice of "both"? It's just silly.Anyone who can't make up their mind to choose which is the better one in the end can just choose "Both" ... ..

[vivi_g]

Topic: "Which song fo you prefer?"

I thought Kee Hee Sun and Jackie Chan sounds better although I like Han Hong voice better.The song seem less sad with Han Hong singing ... ...

When I was looking at the poll results,I was actually thinking.What's the point and purpose of creating such a poll when you want to know the preference(the better of the two) and there you put a choice of "both"? It's just silly.Anyone who can't make up their mind to choose which is the better one in the end can just choose "Both" ... ..

haha... yeah I realizes that after I had already put the poll on. Is there a way I can delete the "both" option??

[Leanna]

haha... yeah I realizes that after I had already put the poll on. Is there a way I can delete the "both" option??

hahh just put in big bold letter "DONT VOTE FOR BOTH" on ur first post...

[vivi_g]

hahh just put in big bold letter "DONT VOTE FOR BOTH" on ur first post...

Thanks for the suggestion. I'll do that right now.

[Guo Xiang]

The lyrics in Jackie's version are like so, duh.

Personally, the lyrics and vocals for Sun Nan and Han Hong's version are better.

I like the Jackie Chan version only because of Kim Hee Sun's vocals, and it adds a touch of uniqueness when she sings in Korean.

[Sugar]

I liked Han Hong than Kim Hee Sun. I thought KHS's sounded more generic and ... I think lots more people can sing like KHS

I liked Han Hong more because her voice is more unique and sings much cleaner and technical