Mit Jeut See Tai vs. Yeung Siu

[Ken Cheng]

During HSDS, these two characters hated each other (because of Gei Hiu Fu and other issues), but never actually fought each other directly. Who would have won had they fought?

[yittz]

It seems MJ, Kong monks and Wudang 7 are similar. Fan Yao fought with MJ minus her sword. It seems Fan Yao can hold her off without hurting her. So I reckon YX>MJ if she doesn't have her cheap sword.

Also, the purple dragon was more than evenly matched with MJ if the weapons were even. Imo YX a bit better than the 4 guardians.

[batmankiller]

it's the two protectors then the 4 guardians so yeah.. I think YX>FY in internal and FY>YX technique

[jhudsui]

It seems MJ, Kong monks and Wudang 7 are similar. Fan Yao fought with MJ minus her sword. It seems Fan Yao can hold her off without hurting her. So I reckon YX>MJ if she doesn't have her cheap sword.

Also, the purple dragon was more than evenly matched with MJ if the weapons were even. Imo YX a bit better than the 4 guardians.

I thought Left and Right were, martial arts wise, on more or less the same level as the Four Kings, and that Purple Dragon was the best of the Four Kings. I am pretty confident that if MJ + Heaven Sword beats Purple Dragon with staff it beats YX with sword too. Also I think we're told MJ is in the top five for sword techniques and no one ever says anything nice about YX for sword technique, so probably even if they both have normal swords.

YX's understanding of Qiankun Reversal is probably too shallow, and MJ is probably too fast, for him to be able to pull it off against her. Other than the Reversal I don't know much about YX's skills, though.

MK gives the impression of being less powerful than she actually is because she gets a lot of screentime flailing uselessly at ZWJ.

[Dennis Chen]

Also, the purple dragon was more than evenly matched with MJ if the weapons were even. Imo YX a bit better than the 4 guardians.

Especially with knowledge of the 1st stage of QKDNY.

[yittz]

I thought Left and Right were, martial arts wise, on more or less the same level as the Four Kings, and that Purple Dragon was the best of the Four Kings. I am pretty confident that if MJ + Heaven Sword beats Purple Dragon with staff it beats YX with sword too. Also I think we're told MJ is in the top five for sword techniques and no one ever says anything nice about YX for sword technique, so probably even if they both have normal swords.

YX's understanding of Qiankun Reversal is probably too shallow, and MJ is probably too fast, for him to be able to pull it off against her. Other than the Reversal I don't know much about YX's skills, though.

MK gives the impression of being less powerful than she actually is because she gets a lot of screentime flailing uselessly at ZWJ.

Purple Dragon wasn't better than the other 3. She is a lot younger and was only given the position as a sort of respect from the other 3. In internal, YX was evenly matched with white brows, who imo is the best out of the 4 guardians (though lion had potential to be better if he wasn't blind). External wise, YX is similar to FY, they know so much.

Also YX easily embarrassed MJ's apprentice brother/sister - took the heaven blade off her, and chucked it on the ground.

My pick is YX, if he burrows dragon sabre, if not he will have much trouble against the heaven sword.

[Ken Cheng]

Also I think we're told MJ is in the top five for sword techniques and no one ever says anything nice about YX for sword technique, so probably even if they both have normal swords.

Yan Lei Ting (Mo Dong Hero # 6) was said to have been the best swordsman among the Mo Dong 7 Heroes, but Yeung Siu was able to best him in sword combat, implying that Yeung Siu is no mean swordsman himself.

[yittz]

I think is was white brows who faught number 6? Or did they meet again? But either way, it puts YX above no6 in sword art.

[Ken Cheng]

I think is was white brows who faught number 6? Or did they meet again? But either way, it puts YX above no6 in sword art.

White Eyebrowed Eagle King fought Hero # 7 (Mok Sing Guk) during the Battle of Gwong Ming Peak, but unless TVB has lied to me again, Yan Lei Ting dueled Yeung Siu briefly when he first discovered Yeung Siu's affair with Gei Hiu Fu (somehow, I sense this is one of those TVB "value-added" scenes).

[yittz]

Yeah I think it was 7 now.

I think #6 under Z3F improved more than YX in sword arts, at Ming peak though.

[charbydis]

I'd always thought that YX was never a technique person though he could use any object as a weapon and is very flexible in attacking styles. Mie Jue's fighting skills are based on that she gives powerful blows every palm and can take down her opponents easily by injuring them the most in the least amount of tme. But I think YX would be able to evade her blows, tire her out, then steal her sword and then launch his attack.