Ranking the Weapon Skills in the jy canon

[munenori]

How would you rank the top weapon skills in jy's stories from greatest to worst?

Here's the weapon skills that i know of off the top of my head:

- yang guo's heavy iron sword techniques
- pik che swordplay
- DKCB's dugu 9 swordplay
- cheung 3 fong's taiji swordplay
- Beggar Clan's beat-dog stick

Also a side-question, would a fighter with a weapon have a huge advantage against a fighter using only his palms? e.g. is hung 7 gung with his beat-dog stick more dangerous than hung 7 gung with his hong long 18palms?

[the.raven]

How would you rank the top weapon skills in jy's stories from greatest to worst?

Here's the weapon skills that i know of off the top of my head:

- yang guo's heavy iron sword techniques
- pik che swordplay
- DKCB's dugu 9 swordplay
- cheung 3 fong's taiji swordplay
- Beggar Clan's beat-dog stick

Also a side-question, would a fighter with a weapon have a huge advantage against a fighter using only his palms? e.g. is hung 7 gung with his beat-dog stick more dangerous than hung 7 gung with his hong long 18palms?

DG9J is definitely the best, followed by pikachu swordplay.

[flamer]

DG9J probably takes it.

JY said himself that DG9J>Bixie.

[wuyuejin]

Dugu 9 Jian > everything else, including YG's Heavy Jet Iron Sword. The sword arts used by the chick in Yue Nu Jian is very impressive too, as she could single-handedly defeat a whole army.