Originally Posted by
Ken Cheng
Wuxia stories have been adapted for film and television for decades, and literally hundreds of actors and actresses have been cast in these adaptations over the years.
In your opinion, which wuxia actors and actresses, historically, have best captured the true "wuxia" spirit? We're not talking personal favorites or best-looking, but performers who were, in looks, presence, and performance, able to most successfully create a believable wuxia persona. The key is that you look at this actor/actress in character and say, "Yeah...that's totally a wuxia character from medieval times," not "Eh...it's a 20th/21st Century person *trying* to act like a wuxia character, but still looking/acting unmistakably modern."
My picks:
Wong Yeun Sun, who portrayed Sai Mun Chui Sheut and Ah Fei in TVB's 1970s Gu Long adaptations
Leung Ga Yan, who portrayed Kiu Fung in DGSD '81 and the older Gwok Jing in ROCH '83
Bao Fong, who portrayed Cheung 3 Fung in HSDS '86
Idy Chan, who portrayed Wong Yu Yin in DGSD '81 and Little Dragon Girl in ROCH '83
Sharon Yeung, who portrayed Muk Yeun Ching in DGSD '81 and Muk Lim Chi in LOCH '82
Kwan Chung, who portrayed Ging Mo Meng in THE ROMANTIC SWORDSMAN and a host of other wuxia characters during the 1970s and early 1980s
Gong Ngai, who portrayed Gong Nam 7 Freaks leader Ohr Jen Ngok in both the 1980s and 1990s TVB LOCH and ROCH adaptations.
Kwan Hoi San, who portrayed Mo Yung Bok in DGSD '81 and many other wuxia characters during the 1970s and 1980s.
Kenneth Tsang Gong, who portrayed East Heretic Wong Yerk See in LOCH '82/ROCH '83 and Golden Haired Lion King Tse Tsun in HSDS '86
Cheung Lui, who portrayed Kau Mor Tze in DGSD '81, Jebeh in LOCH '82, and the Golden Wheel Monk in ROCH '83.
Cheung Ying Choi, who portrayed Emperor Deun Jing Ming in DGSD '81 and Ma Yuk in LOCH '83/ROCH '83.
These were, I believe, the most convincing wuxia performers I've seen. You might notice that other than Idy Chan, there aren't too many big, headlining stars. That's no indictment of those stars or their acting abilities. Felix Wong, Barbara Yung, Michael Miu, Andy Lau, Tony Leung, etc., are all fine actors who played their roles well, but I still felt like they were modern people performing as wuxia characters. The above named actors, however, really seemed to become wuxia characters from the distant past.