A question that maybe no one can answer**, but I must ask anyway

[PJ]

**unless Athena comes out of retirement

Anyway, in DGSD, Grandfather Tan and Granny Tan are from the Chongxiao cave, which is the same name as Elder Xu Chongxiao, which was only given to him in the 3rd ed. Does Xu Chongxiao now have relations with the cave which bears his name? It was he who invited the Tans to come down, although they needed to come for another reason anyway.

[PJ]

This would be a perfect Q for JY at an interview.

[cafelatte]

do you know who the script writer is for this content? If not do a search for the text or script. If you can find out who the writer is, its likely that you can can contact them through email and ask your question. At least this method will be getting an answer from someone who has the whole rule book.