Mafia: The Huashan Massacre

[Guo Xiang]

Sorry, Odbie. Am I dead?

You are not dead until the story line says you are.

(4) GX's voting for kidd is just an illusion. To shift our attention.

My voting for her was completely random. My voting for you isn't...

[wkeej]

Update for BM:
ByTme: wkeej
Guo Xiang: wkeej
Jadebunny: ?
kidd: ?
remember_cedric: yittz
Ren Ying Ying: wkeej
wkeej: kidd
Jaded:?
yittz: cedric

[kidd]

Still can't decide who to vote. Need to sleep now. Can't think. Will come back 9 hours later.

[Ren Ying Ying]

Before I die as a townie, look at the assumptions. E.g (2). There is no need for kidd to vote now since I have the most votes.
To my fellow townies, think about the combination of GX+kidd.
(1) In BM's story, Yittz was targetted. I was surprised that he is saved by doc. That means that somehow doc knows that Yittz will be targetted. Before I can ask anything, kidd came in to ask whether Yittz, if he is a doctor, can save himself.
(2) Presuming that my thinking with kidd concurs because I think we are the same age, Yittz was targetted by the mafia. In other words, kidd is likely to be the mafia.

To be fair though, kidd asked a legit question that most of us would wonder about.

(3) BM's story has to be true. There is no self-interest in BM to tell a false story because it does not matter who wins in the game.
(4) GX's voting for kidd is just an illusion. To shift our attention.

How are we so sure GX's voting for kidd is just an illusion? What if GX is actually the detective and she knows kidd's identity (if kidd turns out to be mafia).

Anyways, I think we still need majority to vote. We're still at a deadlock. BM is going to be pissed...

[kidd]

I vote for wkeej.

Sorry pal. This vote is for self-preservation.

[Ren Ying Ying]

I vote for Yittz.

Sorry Yittz. This vote is for self-preservation.

how is that self-preservation?

[kidd]

how is that self-preservation?

Sorry. Type the wrong name. Both have been doing a lot of logical analysing and rationalising in the board. I kinda mix them up. Their style seems the same. I read his last analysis right before I voted and I thought of Yittz. That's why I mistakenly put Yiz's name.

I choose wkeej because he has the most vote. So, might as well add in mine.

Wow, you are so fast. I already edit immediately after I post and you still catch it. I won't vote Yittz because he's 80% innocent.

[wkeej]

To be fair though, kidd asked a legit question that most of us would wonder about.

How are we so sure GX's voting for kidd is just an illusion? What if GX is actually the detective and she knows kidd's identity (if kidd turns out to be mafia).

Anyways, I think we still need majority to vote. We're still at a deadlock. BM is going to be pissed...

1. Agreed that it is a fair question. To me, it was asked too fast. As what I say, kidd and I may have same level of thinking as we could be about the same age.
2. Never so sure in such mindgame. GX's vote for kidd is too fast.
3. No more deadlock. :-)

[kidd]

1. Agreed that it is a fair question. To me, it was asked too fast. As what I say, kidd and I may have same level of thinking as we could be about the same age.

I forgot what I said earlier since I have said so many things before. So, I checked back the thread. It seems I asked that question in reply to RYY's 'Well, he is Dr. Yittzie, so he probably just resuscitated himself' comment. So, it's actually RYY's joke comment piquing my curiosity.

[wkeej]

I forgot what I said earlier since I have said so many things before. So, I checked back the thread. I seems I asked that question in reply to RYY's 'Well, he is Dr. Yittzie, so he probably just resuscitated himself' comment. So, it's actually RYY's joke comment piquing my curiosity.

Fair. Maybe I read too much into the words. :-)

[wkeej]

Since I will be "dying" soon, let me put down the "reasons".
1. RYY - "I think i'm putting my vote down for wkeej for now until he can tell me why he's so sure about kidd"
2. GX - "Is voting over yet? If not I want to change my vote to wkeej. He's too suspicious."
3. ByTMe - "I singled Bunny out as suspicious but I vote to lynch wkeej. He's too frustrating."
4. kidd - "I choose wkeej because he has the most vote".

Come, BM, declare me dead. Tell them it is a "BIG" mistake which I cause myself because I am clueless.

[Ren Ying Ying]

edit

updated voting list:
ByTme: wkeej
Guo Xiang: wkeej
Jadebunny: ?
kidd: wkeej
remember_cedric: yittz
Ren Ying Ying: wkeej
wkeej: kidd
Jaded:?
yittz: cedric

i think we need 5 votes for majority since there's 9 of us.

[wkeej]

I am touched. No, don't do that. Actually, I NEED to die so that the game continues. I have actually put that down when RYY said what happened if there is a deadlock. I put something like "If so, let me die as I am going for a 7-day mission next week and I will have no access to Internet". Very unfair for me not to be around. Then, I saw kidd's change of vote. And I edited the sentence to "No more deadlock". :-)

[Ren Ying Ying]

I am touched. No, don't do that. Actually, I NEED to die so that the game continues. I have actually put that down when RYY said what happened if there is a deadlock. I put something like "If so, let me die as I am going for a 7-day mission next week and I will have no access to Internet". Very unfair for me not to be around. Then, I saw kidd's change of vote. And I edited the sentence to "No more deadlock". :-)

fine, perhaps we shall relieve your "pain". btw, where is your trip to?

[odbayarb2000]

Is it Majority or most vote ?

If majority then one more vote is needed. If most vote then wkeej is doomed.

[jadebunny9]

I believe that wkeej is innocent, for some reason. And I'm going to go with Yittz on this one...I vote to lynch Ceddie. Sorry dear. Just a gut feeling.

[Ren Ying Ying]

I believe that wkeej is innocent, for some reason. And I'm going to go with Yittz on this one...I vote to lynch Ceddie. Sorry dear. Just a gut feeling.

Wkeej does sound more innocent. But he's going on a trip next week and is going to be MIA for at least a week. But ceddie also said she's busy . I guess wkeej sounds more innocent for now so I'll change my vote to remember_Cedric

So that's 3 for wkeej and 3 for ceddie

[wkeej]

Wkeej does sound more innocent. But he's going on a trip next week and is going to be MIA for at least a week. But ceddie also said she's busy . I guess wkeej sounds more innocent for now so I'll change my vote to remember_Cedric

So that's 3 for wkeej and 3 for ceddie

Can I die? Better solution: Change my life for Odbie. Poor Odbie, he pop in and out of this forum very now and then. and he died randomly.

My story can end like, "To show his innocence, wkeej took a look at the sword which casted the names of his beloved six brothers/sisters (or seven or eight, including the two mafias - at the moment of death, wkeej is still clueless) and plunged it into his heart".

Alternative ending, "A dart flew out and split wkeej's sword into two. The pointed part dropped to the floor. Everyone looked at the direction of the dart. It is Odbie. Somehow, somehow, ... Because of so many doubts about wkeej, Song Master (correct?) has no choice but to exile wkeej to Mt ... (OT: actually, it will be on a trekking trip to Mt Berkalah (think this is the correct spelling) Falls, Kuantan, West Malaysia. Never been there before. The fun part is that we will be going off-track to collect soil samples and study the rocks. I am not doing these. I am there more for the trekking. Heard that there are tigers there)

[odbayarb2000]

I think there is no point for me return to the game at this stage.


I just wish it progresses quickly. I think we should dictate some time limit.

[yittz]

I think wkeej is innocent
Even though he baffled us with his choices, his reasoning is acceptable.
I don't think he's capable of reverse psych when he is one vote from lynch
We shouldn't give mafia extra night just because he wants to leave. Banh mi could always do double night execution