Mafia: The Huashan Massacre

[wkeej]

This is very much a mind-game. Everyone waiting for someone to do something before he/she takes action.

[jadebunny9]

So BM's story is just taking us on another mind game? Oh blah..........I thought Yittz was targeted and then was miraculously saved.

[Banh Mi]

He might be, or he might not be. Deductive reasoning means eliminating all the uncertainties until all that you're left with is the truth.

[Ren Ying Ying]

So BM's story is just taking us on another mind game? Oh blah..........I thought Yittz was targeted and then was miraculously saved.

Only doctor and mafia should know if BM's story is accurate or not. And if yittzie isn't the one that was really targeted, then doctor should know who the real victim is...and who is truly innocent. And whoever is detective should've been able to be certain if someone is innocent or guilty also. So we should have two (innocent) folks knowing the identity of two others. That's 4 people whose identity could be revealed.

I swear, BM better not be playing that yittzie trick where nobody is mafia and we're just running around headlessly lynching each other off x_x.

[wkeej]

I swear, BM better not be playing that yittzie trick where nobody is mafia and we're just running around headlessly lynching each other off x_x.

Somehow, I have this feeling too. Or maybe only one mafia/townie. :-) Anyway, someone needs to start somewhere. I shall wait as I am still innocently lost on the process. :-)

[yittz]

So are we going to lynch someone, or twiddle our thumbs. Quite frankly we are none the wiser.

[yittz]

He might be, or he might not be. Deductive reasoning means eliminating all the uncertainties until all that you're left with is the truth.

I am confused. So the person saved could be anyone? Can Mafia's pick no one to lynch?
Doesn't that mean others can't be sure I am in the clear.
TBH I don't think Banh Mi will throw us completely off on purpose. It's pretty mean to do a 180 degrees mislead by writing about me like a townie if I am mafia, don't you think? Potentially someone else was saved according to Banh Mi, but unlikely; but almost no likelihood of me being a mafia.

[Banh Mi]

Mafia has to try and kill someone at night. But I can and will definitely throw people off in the storyline. If I perceive there to be an advantage to one side or another, I might throw people off to counter balance. Just sayin'.

[Suet Seung]

Is there a slow type of death where you're hung out in the sun w/o water? The humdity and heat for today's weather where I am is so harsh.

[ByTmE]

Can we torture to interrogate?

[Banh Mi]

Can we torture to interrogate?

So long as it isn't me.

[wkeej]

are you going to lynch mafia or townie now? :-)

[Ren Ying Ying]

are you going to lynch mafia or townie now? :-)

we vote on it.

btw, what is the deadline?

[yittz]

There is someone that I want to lynch. hahahahaha. However, it's a sort of shot in the dark. I'm not inclined to hastily lynch another person after the mistaken lynch of apprentice Odby.

Who do you want to lynch? There's no harm to your survival if you bring in a good case. Given Odb being innocent, there is already a strong case against you.

[ByTmE]

Who do you want to lynch? There's no harm to your survival if you bring in a good case. Given Odb being innocent, there is already a strong case against you.

On the contrary, I do not think there is a strong case against me. In fact, this was stated by yourself earlier. I have not made any unfounded accusations or sneak random attacks against any apprentices (read: shot in the dark or jumping on the band wagon). I am suspicious of those who do, however, because I just don't think it's appropriate to do.

There's just not enough remarks by people to force me to readily make a concrete decision! What's the deal yo. How is this game supposed to work...when it's like this.

[yittz]

Mafias generally wouldn't put their neck on the block by shot in the dark. You didn't point your finger at Odb until jadebunny did so, and half your points were just defending youself. If you suspect someone, and you are townie you should have no reason to fear voicing your concerns. Putting your neck out for the collective good.

Basically now that you won't talk out of your own free will, we make you squeal. tickle tickle tickle

[ByTmE]

Mafias generally wouldn't put their neck on the block by shot in the dark. You didn't point your finger at Odb until jadebunny did so, and half your points were just defending youself.

My first post was not defending myself. I feel indignant at this comment. How come nobody read's carefully enough?! I agree that Mafia members wouldn't generally put their necks out on the chopping block. However, I also think that they are a sneaky bunch who are also capable of thinking of this.

If you suspect someone, and you are townie you should have no reason to fear voicing your concerns. Putting your neck out for the collective good.

Basically now that you won't talk out of your own free will, we make you squeal. tickle tickle tickle

...wouldn't this argument be true for all of us? Yittz, you may vote to lynch me. After the odby incident, though I have my suspicions, I will not be making a call to lynch another apprentice brother or sister. I don't view voting someone to lynch as putting my neck out, rather I view it as calling them out to be hung.

[yittz]

Not asking you to lynch/vote anyone my dear.
Just say who you think is suspicious. If no heat is put on people, mafia will just cruise through.

[ByTmE]

...once bitten, twice shy.

[Ren Ying Ying]

...wouldn't this argument be true for all of us? Yittz, you may vote to lynch me. After the odby incident, though I have my suspicions, I will not be making a call to lynch another apprentice brother or sister. I don't view voting someone to lynch as putting my neck out, rather I view it as calling them out to be hung.

None of us likes to lynch fellow innocent folks, but we need to lynch someone to get the game going--otherwise it's a dead game.

If none of us can gather enough suspicion against anyone else, then we will have to randomly lynch again like we did to fellow brother odbie . Sometimes, the innocent will have to sacrifice for the greater good. We just have to make sure brother odbayard will not die in vain