Mafia: The Huashan Massacre

[ByTmE]

Because the players are so few, there are not many of us to sacrifice though. :T Aren't there just 2 mafia members? A Doctor and a Detective..that's what, 4 apprentices? In addition, I like all of you guys currently playing the game enough not to want to sacrifice any of y'all. Perhaps we need another story, Banh Mi.

Hm, now that I think about it, my numbers might be off. Sorry, Math is not my strong point. :T

[Ren Ying Ying]

Because the players are so few, there are not many of us to sacrifice though. :T Aren't there just 2 mafia members? A Doctor and a Detective..that's what, 4 apprentices? In addition, I like all of you guys currently playing the game enough not to want to sacrifice any of y'all. Perhaps we need another story, Banh Mi.

Hm, now that I think about it, my numbers might be off. Sorry, Math is not my strong point. :T

There's 9 of us. 2 Songshan baddies, 1 doc, 1 detective. So that leaves 5 as regular innocent sect members.

Seriously, if you think someone is suspicious, then voice your suspicion. if you think they are suspicious, then the chances of them being innocent is lower (even if it's just 1%). So lynching a person who you think is 98% innocent is a better than lynching a person you think is 99% innocent .

Or are you just waiting for one us to throw a name out there and see if it matches your thoughts?

[yittz]

Anyone who voted for Odb is suspicious imo.

[jadebunny9]

I don't want to start randomly naming people anymore since the last time I did that someone innocent was murdered. =( Still feeling guilty.

[Ren Ying Ying]

geez, you guys are all such marshmellows.

Fine, I shall brave it through. I'll vote to lynch ceddie since she wants to lynch whoever is hyper-active...and the procrastinator me tends to want to chat a lot .

Plus, since she suggested lynching yittzie right after BM's story. While the story may not be entirely accurate, BM did say he will swing the story one way or another depending on who has the advantage. I don't think the mafia is considered to be at a disadvantage right now since we are all pretty much lost on who mafia is, so the chances are low that BM was trying to trick us into thinking yittzie is innocent when in fact he is actually mafia.

I know we are afraid to kill innocents here, but what needs to be done has to be done. If none of you wants to take the responsibility, then I'll take it. There's no point staying alive in the game if the game doesn't move on.

Of course, I'm just throwing ceddie's name out there on a whim. If you have a better choice and reason *cough*ByTme*cough*, then just voice it out

[ByTmE]

There's 9 of us. 2 Songshan baddies, 1 doc, 1 detective. So that leaves 5 as regular innocent sect members.

Seriously, if you think someone is suspicious, then voice your suspicion. if you think they are suspicious, then the chances of them being innocent is lower (even if it's just 1%). So lynching a person who you think is 98% innocent is a better than lynching a person you think is 99% innocent .

Or are you just waiting for one us to throw a name out there and see if it matches your thoughts?

Really? ::scratches nose:: (if you know me in person, this is largely identified as my "thinking posture" lol)

Thanks Ying Ying! I'm Math stupid. I was thinking of waiting it out like I did the first round, but I'm thinking...that's not fun. haha. I am also inclined to believe that most ppl will be taking a shot in the dark, so the chances of me agreeing with them might not be so high. Odby, put himself out there purposely, but no one else has done the same...possibly protecting themselves from the same fate.

So, I have compiled some notes based upon "suggestions" in the thread which are only partly responsible for my suspicion. In some cases, I am simply going on a hunch. Firstly, I will say this: In no way do I believe that others don't have suspicion in their hearts, I believe you all do.

In my notes, I have written down the names of members and their respective suspicions that have been voiced throughout the thread. In addition, I have also noted how credible their suggestions are, which are also largely hunches...since I am also inclined to believe that some apprentices are more innocent than others. I have compiled a list of who named who as suspicious. Please correct me if I'm wrong in any of the notes or have interpreted your intentions incorrectly. Some of you guys are really subtle, which I may have missed, also.

ByTmE : Ren Ying Ying [not credible]
Guo Xiang : Ren Ying Ying [rebuttal]; jadebunny9 [can't recall why]
jadebunny9 : ByTmE [did not state]; those who DON'T talk alot are suspicious [ugh, haha]
kidd : NONE that I have noticed
remember_Cedric : Yittz [talker] ; those who talk alot are suspicious [ugh, haha]
Ren Ying Ying : Guo Xiang [random, I think]; ByTmE [more than once]; jadebunny9 [ditto]; those who DON'T talk alot are suspicious [zoikes!]
wkeej : Guo Xiang [random, actually ]
xJadedx: MIA has not participated in the game and has named no member
Yittz : NONE that I have noticed; oh wait update, ByTmE; jadebunny9, kidd, remember_Cedric [based on votes for Odby...somewhat credible, I think]

Some members stand out to me more than others, namely the following.

I will be frank, my previous suspicion was jadebunny9 because she changes her stance easily.; I believe 3 times in the last game. I must admit to not knowing this apprentice well though. Will anyone step up to defend her? Is this normal behavior? In contrast, there are some members who are very neutral such as kidd. While being neutral is not suspicious behavior in and of itself, but that speaks to me of an overly cautious apprentice. However, I happen to know that this apprentice is quite busy.Thus I am not suspicious of kidd because of a personal..well bias, you can say.Yittz is a snoop and not gentle about it. However, because one is nosy, it doesn't mean you're guilty. It could just means he is the detective. wkeej is...so random and out there...so I have no idea. BUT THAT IS JUST SO WEIRD! Ren Ying Ying, oddly I feel that I should be suspicious of this apprentice...but I'm just not.

My top choice is jadebunny9. You seem like you could be evil.

[ByTmE]

Oh sorry Ying Ying! I spent the last hour typing my post HAHAHAHA

[Banh Mi]

I thought you guys know how to play this game, accusing each other off the bat. But now you're getting cold feet. People aren't dying for real. It's better to be wrong than to be neutral, nothing gets acomplished with neutrality.

Deadline is end of the weekend since there hasn't been a single official vote.

[ByTmE]

Oh no, we're getting scolded by the narrator

[PJ]

Asians are too nice.

[jadebunny9]

I still stick to my theory that those who don't talk should be suspicious.

[Ren Ying Ying]

Wow...those are pretty detailed observations O_O.

My top choice is jadebunny9. You seem like you could be evil.

Yea, now that you mention it, I was also a little suspicious of bun bun (but I'm suspicious of everyone except myself...so that doesn't say much). But bun bun seems like a "go with the flow" type of person for me though. Who knows, maybe bun bun was on a sugar high that day. lol.

I still stick to my theory that those who don't talk should be suspicious.

But you've been pretty quiet, love.
I think wkeej is pretty innocent. I don't know how you can even try to fake being THAT lost in the game. Jaded is busy with her conference. While she did post once in the other thread, I'll give her the benefit of the doubt right now. A lot of folks are pretty busy (I should be busy doing other stuff...but I'm an ultimate procrastinator and my ADHD is worsening)

Deadline is end of the weekend since there hasn't been a single official vote.

This weekend as in before the weekend STARTS or before the weekend ENDS?

[ByTmE]

Asians are too nice.

Suet Seung and xJadedx could probably attest to the fact that I'm nicer online than in person lol!

[jadebunny9]

I will be frank, my previous suspicion was jadebunny9 because she changes her stance easily.; I believe 3 times in the last game. [/B]

I'm just sorta curious what you mean by this? I didn't even know I had a stance.

[ByTmE]

I'm just sorta curious what you mean by this? I didn't even know I had a stance.

To be clear, I was under the impression that you changed your mind easily...so yeah, it can be said you don't have a stance. That speaks to me of an intention to instigate suspicion among the apprentices if it's intentional. By stance, I meant position or post of suspicion of different people. [1] it was myself [after RYY and Odby pointed me out], [2] then it was the quiet people [after I had my say], and [3] finally, it was Odby that you eventually voted to lynch.

You are not the only one. I'm just going on a hunch/impression. Perhaps, you feel that there are others more suspicious in the same respect that I identified you as being?

[Banh Mi]

Wow...those are pretty detailed observations O_O.



Yea, now that you mention it, I was also a little suspicious of bun bun (but I'm suspicious of everyone except myself...so that doesn't say much). But who knows, maybe bun bun was on a sugar high that day. lol.


But you've been pretty quiet, love.
I think wkeej is pretty innocent. I don't know how you can even try to fake being THAT lost in the game. Jaded is busy with her conference. While she did post once in the other thread, I'll give her the benefit of the doubt right now. A lot of folks are pretty busy (I should be busy doing other stuff...but I'm an ultimate procrastinator and my ADHD is worsening)


This weekend as in before the weekend STARTS or before the weekend ENDS?

End of the weekend. Unless we have a majority vote by that time. Get cracking peeps, lets see some blood.

[jadebunny9]

To be clear, I was under the impression that you changed your mind easily...so yeah, it can be said you don't have a stance. That speaks to me of an intention to instigate suspicion among the apprentices if it's intentional. By stance, I meant position or post of suspicion of different people. [1] it was myself [after RYY and Odby pointed me out], [2] then it was the quiet people [after I had my say], and [3] finally, it was Odby that you eventually voted to lynch.

You are not the only one. I'm just going on a hunch/impression. Perhaps, you feel that there are others more suspicious in the same respect that I identified you as being?

Everyone was just pointing fingers around randomly since we still don't have a lot of clues, and I was one of them. Actually, I'm still going to be pointing fingers around randomly until I find someone super suspicious. Unfortunately, I don't have anyone yet.

[Ren Ying Ying]

To her credit, my impression is that bunny seems to be the type to kind of "go with the flow" as long as the game moves foward type of person. Though, I don't think that necessarily clears her of suspision.

[kidd]

Oh no, we're getting scolded by the narrator

Banh Mi is getting very impatient because the game isn't moving and he's getting bored. I'm surprised that he gave us until end of the weekend (3 days) instead of tomorrow.

[wkeej]

Anyone who voted for Odb is suspicious imo.

Those who do not vote is even more suspicious?? Anyway, I did not vote because I was in the other thread.