Jinyong been long seen as Tolkien of the east but none of his works been properly and very very seriously filmed with international quality and carefully casted to match standards like "lord of the rings"
In commercial, artistic and social value? Which novel of Jinyong will be the best to be filmed with top international standard..with
-Top quality screenplay.
-Top historically accurate wardrobe.
-Carefully chosen cast.
-With provoking issue that arouse western audience.
-Complex but good plot.
Personally, I find "Tian Long Ba Bu"the best.
Firstly for screenplay, it had great screenplay of different locations like Dali, Song empire, Khitan and etc.
For wardrobe, if its meticulously and accurate made. It will be a good attarctive point.
Good example of oscars awarding films with wardrobe related: Gandhi, The last emperor, Crouching dragon hidden Dragon and Lincoln
Cast is crucial.
For issue... TIan Long tackled one big issue that reflects america: Racism. Qiao Feng seen like a barbarian. And suffered racism. In the end, he died to prove his innocence. Duan Yu is not a Han so seen as a foreign race. The only main stream race that support them is XuZhu: a true blue Han chinese.
To exaggerately put in western concept, Qiao Feng is like a Barbarian, Duan Yu a elf. While Xu Zhu just a peasant.
Even in the west, Barbarians faced lots of discrimination during ancient europe times.
If the script is carefully written, cast carefully chosen and a good director chosen.. It may shock western audience.