Sunflower scroll (KHBD) was created by a husband and wife?

[Stance]

I know the sunflower scroll (KHBD) was created by a eunuch, but I heard in a previous edition, the sunflower scroll was created by a husband and wife. The husband created the internal and the wife created sword part and both couldn't connect and conflicted with each other.

Is this true in previous editions? Any guess as to who the husband and wife is? YG and XLN?

[Western Eccentric]

You're right in old edition that was creates by husband/wife but they "separated" like enemy after the manual created..
As for The Yang's couple I think it's quite wild imagination

[Stance]

You're right in old edition that was creates by husband/wife but they "separated" like enemy after the manual created..
As for The Yang's couple I think it's quite wild imagination

Just for fun, lets run with the old edition's husband and wife as the creator. Any guess as to who was the creators? The couple would've had to be quite powerful and existed around the Yuan dynasty?

[CC]

In the 1st edition of JY's works, it was not even called KHBD. It was Qian Kun Upper and Lower book (or something like that). A 2 part martial arts which many speculated to be created by WCY and LCY.

[a_tumiwa]

Just for fun, lets run with the old edition's husband and wife as the creator. Any guess as to who was the creators? The couple would've had to be quite powerful and existed around the Yuan dynasty?

was it stated that they lived around yuan dynasty era?

[Western Eccentric]

If I'am not wrong they come from North Song Dynasty🐼🐼🐼🐼perhaps around Huang Shang era..

[Stance]

A little history about the original version is written here.

https://zh.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/葵花宝典

[Stance]

In the 1st edition of JY's works, it was not even called KHBD. It was Qian Kun Upper and Lower book (or something like that). A 2 part martial arts which many speculated to be created by WCY and LCY.

If it was WCY, did he had to chop? 😁

[Ken Cheng]

If it was WCY, did he had to chop? 😁

He got to # 1 in wulin without that nonsense.

[CC]

If it was WCY, did he had to chop? 😁

The Hua Shan guys only got hold of 1 of the books.

Assume it was the LCY version.

I didn't read the whole 1st edition. Assume that whatever appeared in SOD was a rather watered down and corrupted version.

[Stance]

The Hua Shan guys only got hold of 1 of the books.

Assume it was the LCY version.

I didn't read the whole 1st edition. Assume that whatever appeared in SOD was a rather watered down and corrupted version.

From what i can gather the Hua Shan guys got both books and each read 1. They didn't realise the 2 never meant to connect and conflicted with each other.