Can we combine Yin and Yang ?

[a_tumiwa]

topic: in jin yong universe, can a martial artist practice or combine Yin and Yang energy / martial arts? i have searched, found some related threads but cannot find satisfied answer

[wkeej]

No martial arts expert, isn't tai-chi supposed to a balance of yin and yang? Use yin against yang and yang against yin.

[Mandred Skavenslayer]

To an extent all martial arts must balance Yin & Yang.
Take for examples 18 Dragon Palm & Tai Chi.
18DP is considered the most power external/hard martial art, yet the emphasis is on control and subtlety.
Tai Chi is the softest art, but when attacking crashes down with the weight of the Oceans.

[wkeej]

Possibly a_t is interested to find out what's if someone learn 9-yang and 9-yin together?

[a_tumiwa]

Possibly a_t is interested to find out what's if someone learn 9-yang and 9-yin together?

yeah thats too

[wkeej]

Scientifically, it should be fine. It's like eating durian (yang) and mangosteen (yin).

[Western Eccentric]

Did SPT is the only person in JY universe which can "combine" Yin and Yang but it's like due to "freak accident" but if Yu mean combining Yin/Yang with "normal training" I think no one in JY novel can do it..

[a_tumiwa]

Did SPT is the only person in JY universe which can "combine" Yin and Yang but it's like due to "freak accident" but if Yu mean combining Yin/Yang with "normal training" I think no one in JY novel can do it..

yes it should be like that, but some evindence contrary to the fact , like Guo Jing who is Yang and hard but later learned 9-Yin.

[Stance]

Z3F knew some of 9yang before creating tai chi. Wouldn't this mean he has both flowing through his body?

[wkeej]

Can zwj's words in series be trusted? He just told zzr that 9 yang is not suitable for females.

[Ken Cheng]

Can zwj's words in series be trusted? He just told zzr that 9 yang is not suitable for females.

I think Cheung Mo Gei misunderstood what was going on. While he was using 9 Yeung inner power to heal Chow Chi Yerk's injuries, he noticed a countering yin force emanating from her body. Cheung Mo Gei wrongly believed that what was resisting his 9 Yeung inner power was Ngor Mei Sect inner power, but actually, it was the 9 Yum energy that Chow Chi Yerk had acquired from having started secretly training in the 9 Yum Jen Ging.

[wkeej]

I think Cheung Mo Gei misunderstood what was going on. While he was using 9 Yeung inner power to heal Chow Chi Yerk's injuries, he noticed a countering yin force emanating from her body. Cheung Mo Gei wrongly believed that what was resisting his 9 Yeung inner power was Ngor Mei Sect inner power, but actually, it was the 9 Yum energy that Chow Chi Yerk had acquired from having started secretly training in the 9 Yum Jen Ging.

In this series, zzr asked zwj to teach her 9-yang and the great shift. Then zwj noted that 9-yang is not suitable for females.

[Ken Cheng]

In this series, zzr asked zwj to teach her 9-yang and the great shift. Then zwj noted that 9-yang is not suitable for females.

...which flies in the face of the fact that it's at the root of Ngor Mei Sect martial arts, invented by a female named Gwok Seung.

[a_tumiwa]

$this->handle_bbcode_img_match('http://www.spcnet.tv/forums/images/misc/quote_icon.png') Originally Posted by Stance $this->handle_bbcode_img_match('http://www.spcnet.tv/forums/images/buttons/viewpost-right.png')
Z3F knew some of 9yang before creating tai chi. Wouldn't this mean he has both flowing through his body?



Wuji once said to zhou zhiruo that probably only Zhang Sanfeng can combine yin and yang.
but at that time Wuji already learned Taiji/ Tai chi .
isnt that awkward?

[a_tumiwa]

...which flies in the face of the fact that it's at the root of Ngor Mei Sect martial arts, invented by a female named Gwok Seung.

so that's mean Jin Yong's plothole?
or Wuji just didnt want to taught zhou zhiruo , so he just made an excuse

[wkeej]

so that's mean Jin Yong's plothole?
or Wuji just didnt want to taught zhou zhiruo , so he just made an excuse

Anyway, zwj did note that he is willing to teach zzr the Great Shift skills.

[Western Eccentric]

Ironically one of the few people which knew "full volume" Qian Kun Skill (even with Persian part) at that time is "women" (i.e Xiao Zhao)😛😛😛😛

[Ken Cheng]

Ironically one of the few people which knew "full volume" Qian Kun Skill (even with Persian part) at that time is "women" (i.e Xiao Zhao)😛😛😛😛

Nothing unusual about that. The leader of the Persian Ming Cult is customarily a woman.

[Western Eccentric]

Yeahhh but Qian Kun was "lost" for over 300 years which only Ming China have the "full manual"..

[MisterM]

In ROCH Gong Sun Zhi had a skill called "Yin Yang Twin Blades" which was powerful, however I'm not sure if we can count that as practicing or combining both Yin and Yang skills?