Divine Finger Snap vs. 1 Yeung Finger: which has better range?

[Ken Cheng]

Which has greater effective striking range: East Heretic Wong Yerk See's Divine Finger Snap or South Emperor 1 Deng's 1 Yeung Finger Technique?

[pannonian]

Yideng and GWM were exchanging finger fire and palm blasts at 1 zhang (10 feet). Huang Yaoshi fired a pebble at GWM from several zhang which shook his wheel and hurt his face with the fragments.

[LuNaR]

Yideng and GWM were exchanging finger fire and palm blasts at 1 zhang (10 feet). Huang Yaoshi fired a pebble at GWM from several zhang which shook his wheel and hurt his face with the fragments.

i think YY finger is better because in a longer exchange of fight, HYS would run out of pebbles to shoot whereas YD can continue to shoot his finger and close the gap. HYS prob have advantage initially with a longer distance attack but dont think he can beat YD that quickly, so in a drawn out fight i say YD wins

[Western Eccentric]

HYS Dan Zhi Shen Tong was better in "long range" but for "close range" YD Yiyang Finger better..

[a_tumiwa]

i dont know which one is more powerful, but yes, HYS's flicking finger has a longer attack range than yiyang finger , cmiiw in loch it was stated.

[Western Eccentric]

If We talk about "power" Yiyang Zhi > Mighty Finger but in terms of "versatility" Mighty Finger was better since could fired in short or long range attack..

[a_tumiwa]

i think YY finger is better because in a longer exchange of fight, HYS would run out of pebbles to shoot whereas YD can continue to shoot his finger and close the gap. HYS prob have advantage initially with a longer distance attack but dont think he can beat YD that quickly, so in a drawn out fight i say YD wins

i believe HYS divine flicking finger doesnt require the use of pebble, it can be used as LDA too

[Stance]

Does HYS walk around with a sack of rocks?

Like in the middle of a fight, it'll be inconvient to be searching around for pebbles and rocks to flick.

[wkeej]

From the tv series, it appears that 1Y requires the use of inner power and flicking finger just requires flicking some rocks/small objects. Range-wise the former wins but speed wise it is the latter.

[Doc Kwok]

The divine finger snap can be used to attack the opponent's body directly - it only needs pebbles when attacking at long range. Examples of that happening include:

• HYS fighting against OYF on Huashan (he tried to flick OYF but got his finger bitten instead)
• YG against Wu Santong
• HYS using it to knock out the 3 Mongolian mercenaries in his friendly contest with YG

[pannonian]

Does HYS walk around with a sack of rocks?

Like in the middle of a fight, it'll be inconvient to be searching around for pebbles and rocks to flick.

With sufficient internal energy, a wooden sword can have the force of a steel sword. And with enough advancement, anything can be a sword: a branch, a blade of grass.

Can't he pick his nose and flick the bogey at an opponent?

[Stance]

With sufficient internal energy, a wooden sword can have the force of a steel sword. And with enough advancement, anything can be a sword: a branch, a blade of grass.

Can't he pick his nose and flick the bogey at an opponent?

Yeah or some ear wax?