The Great Unified Favorite Jin Yong Novel Poll Thread

[k_ge_zhi_wang]

i voted for xiao ao jiang hu. so far - xajh - 29, dgsd - 21, loch - 20, hsds - 11, roch - 9, domd - 7, b & s - 2, other - 3.

[tvbthemevideo]

I love ROCH...

[Knight Storm]

For me its LOCH, ROCH, HSDS (yeah pretty much the trilogy), along with XAJH.

[Bei Rongkun]

i like condor trilogy with HSDS is my most favorite. My other favorite is Smilling proud wanderer.

[Buffy_85]

I've never read any of those books but I saw the tv shows of it. I vote for LOCH because I like the old version play by Felix and Barbara.

[boycetwc]

Originally posted by Han Solo
DSGD is cool. However it is seperated by 70-100 years with the LOCH. HSDS on the other hand have more in common with LOCH and ROCH, in terms that lots of kungfu esp. 9 Yin and characters such as Chang 3 Feng, his master, Guo Fu etc were carried forward to HSDS.

I would just like to comment that of the three later works by JY: DOMD, XAJH and DSGD, i'm surprised that DOMD is not receiving much considerations in this poll. DOMD is after all, perhaps the definitive masterpiece of JY in that he finally created a "hero " in a wuxia novel that does not know a lot of kungfu, thus creating a new shift in this genre that he helped popularised.

Han Solo, thanks for the info... does anyone know if a copy of the translated DOMD can be found anywhere on the net?

The published translated copy is very much over-priced!!

[alecforever815]

wuts your fav jy novel? (tv series applies as well iguess) i can only fit in ten, so i just picked ten novesl out of the 12

[PJ]

Hi,

This topic has been covered previously: http://www.spcnet.tv/forums/showthre...light=favorite

[trizz251]

Can you tell us the percentage of vote for each novel.

[PJ]

bumpers

Currently
---
Demi Gods Semi Devils (Tian Long Ba Bu) 26 21.67%
Legend of Condor Heroes (She Diao Ying Xiong Zhuan) 23 19.17%
Return of the Condor Heroes (Shen Diao Xia Lu) 13 10.83%
The Heaven Sword and Dragon Sabre (Yi Tian Tu Long Ji) 16 13.33%
Smiling Pround Wanderer (Xiao Au Jiang Hu) 30 25.00%
The Duke of Mount Deer (Lu Ding Ji) 7 5.83%
The Book and the Sword (Shu Jian En Chou Lu) 2 1.67%
Other 3 2.50%

[TaiHan]

I voted for LOCH and XAJH.

I didn't know that XAJH was that popular.

[Xiao Feng]

DGSD all the way!

[superboy]

I'm a bit suprised by the results. I thought that it will only come down to DGSD, LOCH, and ROCH.

[Xiao Feng]

It might have something to do with some guys voting for favourite"S" instead of plain old favourite.

I see guys voting for LOCH or ROCH or HSDS also vote for XAJH.

Go figure.

[TaiHan]

Originally posted by Xiao Feng
It might have something to do with some guys voting for favourite"S" instead of plain old favourite.

I see guys voting for LOCH or ROCH or HSDS also vote for XAJH.

Go figure.

and I'm one of them.

[Xiao Feng]

Originally posted by TaiHan
and I'm one of them.

That as much is obvious

[skywise]

DGSD and XAJH is neck and neck!! 31% each! Tx to my vote for DGSD. XAJH was good read but had some despicable characters in it that put me off!

[Xiao Feng]

Originally posted by skywise
DGSD and XAJH is neck and neck!! 31% each! Tx to my vote for DGSD. XAJH was good read but had some despicable characters in it that put me off!

Not to mention the number of dudes who would chop off their own wee wee's for power or fame

[PJ]

it must be bumped.

Come on where are the XAJH fans?! How could you let DGSD take the lead?

Then again DGSD is my fav too so I am happy with the results

nevertheless, I am not a fan of the fact that hardly any discussion is seeing on this forum about Flying Fox, Royal Blood, Mount Deer, Book / Sword, Linked City, and the short stories.

[SKYLINE GT-R 32]

Voted for the trilogy and DGSD