Jia Yi vs Ming Yu

[”~‹á�á]

We know that Jia Yi Shen Gong & Ming Yu Shen Gong are invincible, but which is more powerful? No one knows the answer as Jia Yi has never fight with Ming Yu... but which do u think it's more powerful?

In Legendary Siblings GL gives me an impression of Ming Yu is slightly powerful than Jia Yi, but in the comics version, the author(comic author) gives me the impression of Jia Yi Sheng Gong is more superior than Ming Yu Shen Gong althought Yan Nantian & Yaoyue princess are unbeatable when they fight each another in the comic.

One question...
Besides Shen Lang & Tie Zhong Tang, is there anyone else who also mastered/learn Ming Yu Shen Gong or Jia Yi Shen Gong?

[TigerWong]

Originally posted by ”~‹á�á
In Legendary Siblings GL gives me an impression of Ming Yu is slightly powerful than Jia Yi

That's funny. Because the novel gave me an impression that Jia Yi is slightly more powerful than Ming Yu.

One question...
Besides Shen Lang & Tie Zhong Tang, is there anyone else who also mastered/learn Ming Yu Shen Gong or Jia Yi Shen Gong?

As far as I know, only Yan NanTian, Tie ZhongTang, the woman who transfered her energy to Tie ZhongTang, and I guess the founders of the Big Flag Clan knew Jia Yi Shen Gong.

And in some versions of the Legendary Siblings, it's mentioned that Shen Lang, Xiao WangSun, the Purple Marquis, and either the Night Emperor or the Day Empress knew Ming Yu Shen Gong. In addition to the two Princesses, of course.

[”~‹á�á]

Originally posted by TigerWong
either the Night Emperor or the Day Empress knew Ming Yu Shen Gong.

are those the ppl from Da Qi Ying Xiong Zhuan?

[TigerWong]

Originally posted by ”~‹á�á
are those the ppl from Da Qi Ying Xiong Zhuan?

Yep.

[”~‹á�á]

Originally posted by TigerWong
it's mentioned that Shen Lang, Xiao WangSun, the Purple Marquis, and either the Night Emperor or the Day Empress knew Ming Yu Shen Gong. In addition to the two Princesses, of course.

wait a min... who's Xiao WangSun? which novel he was in?

[Xiao Feng]

We always have ratings for JY martial arts. Its cool to have a GL martial art ranking instead. It would be nice to understand more GL. Why don't we extend this poll to include other martial arts in GL novels. Any takers?

[”~‹á�á]

Originally posted by Xiao Feng
We always have ratings for JY martial arts. Its cool to have a GL martial art ranking instead. It would be nice to understand more GL. Why don't we extend this poll to include other martial arts in GL novels. Any takers?

hey that's a good idea! but i cant edit the poll items... anyway this is a poll within 'Nei Gong Xin Fa', maybe we can start one on 'Wai Men Gong Fu'? How about Xiao Feng or TigerWong start one?

[philip]

hm...not sure which is stronger...but i've always thought ming yu would give more advantage...i mean, taking is always better than giving

[”~‹á�á]

Originally posted by philip
hm...not sure which is stronger...but i've always thought ming yu would give more advantage...i mean, taking is always better than giving

yeah.. that's why i say the novel give me the thought of Ming yu shen gong is better. However, the comic version did make some sense...

In the comic, there was a fight between Yan Nantian & Yaoyue(not in the novel), both who have reached the highest level of their skills, Jia Yi Shen Gong & Ming Yu Sheng Gong. When Yaoyue was absorbing Yan Nantian's blow, she had felt that his internal energy was too 'Gang Meng' & 'Zhi Re' (sorry my english is bad, duno how to translate them) thus she have hard time with him. This does make sense as in the novel, Jia Yi Shen Gong is described as its internal energy is 'Ba Dao', 'gang meng wu bi'. When learned by someone, the one will feel extremely terrible n will be tortured by the Internal energy from Jia Yi Shen Gong as it's really too 'Gang Meng'(strong)!! So maybe the comic is true...
Why Tie Zhong Tang doesnt feel that terrible when the whatever who transfer the Jia Yi Shen Gong internal energy to him? i think it's bcos like the novel said, when Jia Yi is passed down to another guy, its power will be reduced. The real way of learning it is like yan Nantian..

#sorry for my bad language.

[philip]

well, personally, i don't think JiaYi would be more powerful simply cuz it's more "gang meng"....i mean, there is the idea of "soft vs. hard"...and since mingyu is almost the opposite of JiaYi, it's most likely of the "rou" (soft?) element. So it all comes down to ultimate "gang" vs. ultimate "rou"

on a side note...yao yue and yan nan tian are so made for each other...such yin/yang compatibleness. too bad gu long doesn't think like series makers

[TigerWong]

Originally posted by ”~‹á�á
wait a min... who's Xiao WangSun? which novel he was in?

Xiao WangSun is from the Lovers' Arrows. A master of "soft" techniques, his battle with his nemesis Mr.Blue was also mentioned in Little Li's Flying Dagger.