Who would win if there are two Yeung Gor, one use Heavy Iron Sword to fight the other Yeung Gor who will only use Melancholic Palms? Both YG are exactly same, in this case would imply they are post 16yrs.
Printable View
Who would win if there are two Yeung Gor, one use Heavy Iron Sword to fight the other Yeung Gor who will only use Melancholic Palms? Both YG are exactly same, in this case would imply they are post 16yrs.
Guo Jing will win.
I think Zhou Bufan wins seeing as he has reached the peak of perfection in swordplay.Quote:
Originally Posted by CC
They will still be hit by the flying dagger.
(If the MP YG is depressed enough, he would probably win)
While they are fighting, Lee Mok Sau will each flick a poison needle at them. They won't notice at all..., well, until it's too late.
if yang guo uses his MP while he is still sad...he definitely wins...otherwise...i don't know how to judge
YG's internal energy increased alot during the 16 yrs so either way post 16 YG wins
The premise is that both YG are exactly same so they are both post 16yrs.Quote:
Originally Posted by Exodus
Okay, I voted.
Before Yeung Gor could "raise" his right sleeve to use Melancholic Palms, Yeung Gor with the Heavy Iron Sword would have hacked off the other arm thus rendering Yeung Gor arm-less. :D
Heavy Iron Sword pwns Melancholic Palms.
Bottom line is Yeung Gor pwns Yeung Gor.
The good thing about Melancholic Sad Palm is that is it highly manuevable. Even though YG can use the Iron Sword like a regular sword, free hands is still more manuerable than a sword.
In addition, the Melancholic Sad Palm is much wierdier, being able to confuse opponents at times.
The Iron Sword on the other hand has the power advantage.
I'm not too sure, but I'm favoring Melancholic Sad Palm.
One thing you must consider is that this duel is YG vs YG, so they know exactly how to deal with either style.Quote:
Originally Posted by Whsie
They will try to trick each other. None of the tricks work since they know themselves inside out. Then HR comes, says something about XLN at the bottom of a cliff, both jump off the cliff and commit suicide.
Verdict: draw
Then this thread becomes pointless :p since they know exactly how to deal with each other.Quote:
Originally Posted by Yeung Gor
It depends wether you feel one style is more dominant than the other, then there will be a winner eventually, if not that's why there is the option of "draw".Quote:
Originally Posted by JigSta
This hurts the Melancholic Sad Palm more than the Heavy Iron Sword. Sad Palms has a great deal of trickery and weirdness, the benefit of which is largely (although not totally) eliminated when you attempt to use it against the creator of the technique. On the other hand, the Heavy Iron Sword technique is very straightforward and when fighting against it, it's not so much a matter of knowing what to do but rather being able to do it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Yeung Gor
I would give it to Heavy Iron Sword. Yang Guo was able to defeat JLFW in impressive, brute force fashion using it, despite having inferior inner power.
Can brute force of HIS penetrate through the softness of his sleeve?Quote:
Originally Posted by K2Grey
I'm leaning towards Sad Palms. Why would Yeung Gor voluntarily downgrade his martial arts? It would not make sense.
Actually, IMO, YG downgraded his martial arts when he created MP.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken Cheng
Why on earth would he do that, however, unless he didn't anticipate the design flaw of Sad Palms?Quote:
Originally Posted by IcyFox
Beats me. But I think you're right.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken Cheng