Can Duan Yu suck Sweeper Monk or XuZhu's iternal energy?

[flamer]

He managed to suck JMZ's but Xuzhu is way ahead of JMZ and SM even more so.

Will Duan Yu be able to suck their internals with BeiMing?

If not, what about lesser (but still great) people such as the Three Elders of XiaoYao Sect?

[Exodus]

no he can't suck the three elders because they already gave their internal to XZ what DY should've done was to suck XF dry when he was about to die and then suck XZ and Sweeper in the end

[flamer]

no he can't suck the three elders because they already gave their internal to XZ what DY should've done was to suck XF dry when he was about to die and then suck XZ and Sweeper in the end

lol but you think he can do it? Sweeps would fall prey to his sucking? That would certainly make Duan Yu the most powerful fighter in JY universe, cuz whatever opponent comes up, he can just suck him


Yea its a curious thing, why dun people impart their internal before they die? Someone like Xiao Feng, You Tanzhi (he was too sad), Murong Bo/Xiao YuanShan (they dun need it anymore, or maybe to keep them alive for longer), JLFW did not impart his internal to Guo Xiang when he died (it was a sudden death) but there are many instances such as suicide or dying moments (Jue Yuan) that the person is going to die with their massive internals but do not pass them on... Curious....

[Tom]

why dun people impart their internal before they die?

If everyone does that then there would be thousands of Sweepers by now...

And I don't think DY can suck Sweeper...I think you need to have more internal energy than the person to be able to suck him/her. But I'm no expert.

[Exodus]

lol but you think he can do it? Sweeps would fall prey to his sucking? That would certainly make Duan Yu the most powerful fighter in JY universe, cuz whatever opponent comes up, he can just suck him


Yea its a curious thing, why dun people impart their internal before they die? Someone like Xiao Feng, You Tanzhi (he was too sad), Murong Bo/Xiao YuanShan (they dun need it anymore, or maybe to keep them alive for longer), JLFW did not impart his internal to Guo Xiang when he died (it was a sudden death) but there are many instances such as suicide or dying moments (Jue Yuan) that the person is going to die with their massive internals but do not pass them on... Curious....

I don't think that you can transfer your internal to another person permanent without a special skill like BMSG. What might be done was to use up all your internal to clear the ren and du mak to increase ones internal power.

[Tom]

I don't think that you can transfer your internal to another person permanent without a special skill like BMSG.

There's no reason why that can't happen. It's just that Jin Yong never wrote of such an occasion. Bei Ming Shen Gong is a "energy-sucking" martial art, not an "energy-transferring" martial arts. I believe that anyone can transfer their energy is they felt like it. Permanently too.

[The Khan]

If DY sucked XF dry before XF commited suicide, he should have enough internal energy to suck XZ dry. If he did that, there is no way in hell he cannot suck sweeper dry too and become a god

[kidd]

And I don't think DY can suck Sweeper...I think you need to have more internal energy than the person to be able to suck him/her. But I'm no expert.

If that is the case, how come zero internal energy DY can suck the internal energy of people who attacked him in the earlier part of the story?

[flamer]

If that is the case, how come zero internal energy DY can suck the internal energy of people who attacked him in the earlier part of the story?

Exactly


Seriously, why dun people pass on their internals when they are about to die? You can say like they are selfish or want others to work for it... But for ppl like their sons, or relatives, even wives, why wouldnt they pass on to their loved ones, for reasons like better protection, longer life etc.

Even if a special skill is required. Can you imagine XuZhu, on his deathbed, pass on his internal to someone? And then the other person continues etc... it obviously doesnt happen, but why not is the question

[kyss of the sword]

duan yu cannot suck XuZhu's energy because they both have BMSG/BMZQ which would block the others attempt to absorb energy. sweeper monk probably has to much control over his qi and can negate DY's attempt to suck his energy just like fangshang negated ren woxing's ability to absorb his energy.

there's levels of energy transfering. some people transfer energy to help their injured friends recover. some can help transfer qi to help others progress in qi cultivation, helping them break through difficult accupoints/meridiens.

to transfer one's whole inner power may be a risker and dangerous thing. you may need to be at a certain level to accomplish it and the exhaustion that follows could lead to death. also the person you transfer power to needs to know a high level cultivation technqiue to move and cultivate the qi he received or the qi may waste itself. that is why, when injured people recieve high amounts of qi, they recover but do not gain in innwer power levels. they are too ill to cultivate the qi properly.

[flamer]

There's no reason why that can't happen. It's just that Jin Yong never wrote of such an occasion. Bei Ming Shen Gong is a "energy-sucking" martial art, not an "energy-transferring" martial arts. I believe that anyone can transfer their energy is they felt like it. Permanently too.

duan yu cannot suck XuZhu's energy because they both have BMSG/BMZQ which would block the others attempt to absorb energy. sweeper monk probably has to much control over his qi and can negate DY's attempt to suck his energy just like fangshang negated ren woxing's ability to absorb his energy.

there's levels of energy transfering. some people transfer energy to help their injured friends recover. some can help transfer qi to help others progress in qi cultivation, helping them break through difficult accupoints/meridiens.

to transfer one's whole inner power may be a risker and dangerous thing. you may need to be at a certain level to accomplish it and the exhaustion that follows could lead to death. also the person you transfer power to needs to know a high level cultivation technqiue to move and cultivate the qi he received or the qi may waste itself. that is why, when injured people recieve high amounts of qi, they recover but do not gain in innwer power levels. they are too ill to cultivate the qi properly.

yea i agree but i was thinking more on the lines of a top expert on his/her deathbed (or near dying). EG when Xuzhu, Huang Yaoshi (to Huang Rong), is dying, will he pass on his internal? I think not but why not

[sarakoth]

If everyone does that then there would be thousands of Sweepers by now...

And I don't think DY can suck Sweeper...I think you need to have more internal energy than the person to be able to suck him/her. But I'm no expert.

That's not true. Duan Yu went from no energy to some by sucking the seven crappy disciples.

[kyss of the sword]

DY had 'learnt' the technqie but had not practised it, but he had set his energy passage to absorb energy through he wasn't capable yet of doing it. then the infinite sect fighter hit DY right on his vital accuoint, accidentally forcing the energy into his 'ocean of energy'. that bit of energy became the base for DY to practise his energy. DY exercised his energy by practsing LBWW and accuquired enough energy to absorb small amounts of energy. then he got in to a tussel with the guard while trying to escape. the guard accidentally grabbed his thumb through which DY absorbed the energy, the guard used more force but DY kept absorbing his energy and the guard kept using more energy to hold him. DY couldn't extract his thumb from the guards grip or stop absorbing energy, the guard began to feel weak and he shouted for help.his martial brothers came and jumped on top of them to pin down DY. as DY's energy became bigger, he abosrbed the energy faster till the guards lost all their energy. but it was the guards foolishness that they did not realise what was happening till it was to late for them. what we learn.
you can only absorb as much power as you have. but as you absorb energy, it can increase your capacity while you absorb it. but if your opponents inner power is still stronger, he can break the conduict. if you try to absorb a greater amount at once, you risk sending your energy to the other person instead.

[PJ]

If consent is had (by that I mean Xuzhu and Sweeper Monk offer themselves), I don't see any reason why Duan Yu or Linghu Chong or Ren Woxing wouldn't be able to absorb from Sweeper Monk or Xuzhu. Only problem is Duan Yu would die of buffer overflow, as Beiming Shengong doesn't like it when you absorb more than you already have. But he can absorb now and die later.

[PJ]

By the way, I wonder if they can absorb from a fresh dead guy.
The internal energy should still be in the dantian;
I don't think it just flows out of the body when the person dies.

[Wu Wudi]

PJ, was it ever explained why the two old ladies of Xiaoyu sect didn't just gain power by absorbing internal power from others?

[CC]

If consent is had (by that I mean Xuzhu and Sweeper Monk offer themselves), I don't see any reason why Duan Yu or Linghu Chong or Ren Woxing wouldn't be able to absorb from Sweeper Monk or Xuzhu. Only problem is Duan Yu would die of buffer overflow, as Beiming Shengong doesn't like it when you absorb more than you already have. But he can absorb now and die later.

If there was consent, there should not be any worry about overflow. Just leech 5%, break off, then leech 6%, break off etc etc. You won't leech more then what you currently have in this manner.

In any case, why didn't XZ explode when WYZ pumped all that juice into his weak arse? And when he later took LQS and TSTL's energies, he suffered before they were merged but once it all entered him permanently, he was fine immediately.

Basically, you can do what you want as long as the plot warrants it.

[Wu Wudi]

Basically, you can do what you want as long as the plot warrants it.

$this->handle_bbcode_img_match('http://images.jupiterimages.com/common/detail/08/84/23458408.jpg')

[PJ]

PJ, was it ever explained why the two old ladies of Xiaoyu sect didn't just gain power by absorbing internal power from others?

I don't think Tonglao and Li Qiushui knew Beiming Shengong.
It wasn't even said that Wuyazi knew Beiming Shengong,
but most readers believe he did b/c somebody in Xiaoyao Pai had to know!
And he was the sect leader, so he should know some neat tricks.
Plus, he was able to wipe out Xuzhu's internal, presumably using BMSG.

[PJ]

If there was consent, there should not be any worry about overflow. Just leech 5%, break off, then leech 6%, break off etc etc. You won't leech more then what you currently have in this manner.

Very true.

In any case, why didn't XZ explode when WYZ pumped all that juice into his weak arse? And when he later took LQS and TSTL's energies, he suffered before they were merged but once it all entered him permanently, he was fine immediately.

Possibility #1 - Wuyazi didn't use Beiming Shengong.

#2 - Inserting internal energy does not cause overflow whereas absorbing does. Because the energy wasn't transferred by hand, but by head, via a very good feeling.