Hypothetical Question : Quanzhen Sect vs Peach Blossom Island Disciples

[Silverhawk]

If Huang Yaoshi did not cripple his disciples and the two traitors did not steal the nine yin manual, how well would they do in a match against Quanzhen 7 disciples?

[jayjenxi]

They would at least make a stand?

[Western Eccentric]

You mean 7 vs 7 or 1 vs 1 if 1 vs 1 I think HYS side might be win but if 7 vs 7 no could break QZ Big Dipper Formation except Greats..

[Silverhawk]

I mean 1 vs 1

7 vs 7 I agree the QZ will win without much issues

[Western Eccentric]

If 1 vs 1 HYS side would win 4 out of 7 IMHO since Tan Chuduan/Hao Datong/Lu Chuxuan/Sun Bu'er not as good as Qiu Chuji/Ma Yu/Wang Chuyi while almost HYS discipline almost as good as MCF which only slightly inferior to Qiu Chuji/Ma Yu..

[Mandred Skavenslayer]

It depends on what state team Peach Blossom is in and how highly we think of HYS's creativity.

If HYS's students had not betrayed him then at the beginning of LOCH all of them would be better than Lu Chengfeng. Also HYS would have had 16 years to come up with a counter formation to the Big Dipper formation, with a group of students as in sync as the Quanzhen 7.

[Silverhawk]

It depends on what state team Peach Blossom is in and how highly we think of HYS's creativity.

If HYS's students had not betrayed him then at the beginning of LOCH all of them would be better than Lu Chengfeng. Also HYS would have had 16 years to come up with a counter formation to the Big Dipper formation, with a group of students as in sync as the Quanzhen 7.

LCF was the weakest among the lot? Always though Fung Mofeng was the weakest.

I recalled HYS had another student but that one died a long time ago, Wu Mianfeng

[Western Eccentric]

LCF was the weakest among the lot? Always though Fung Mofeng was the weakest.

I recalled HYS had another student but that one died a long time ago, Wu Mianfeng

Lu Chengfeng might be not as good as MCF/Ma Yu but I think he is better than Hao Datong or Sun Bu'er and for Feng Mofeng he is better than Tan Chuduan IMHO since he could "hold on" LMC which considered as good as MCF and Tan Chuduan almost 1 kill K.O by MCF..

[hyoyatika]

I mean 1 vs 1

7 vs 7 I agree the QZ will win without much issues

Rubbish.

MCF was fighting the QZ 7 and losing just by a bit.

If HYS' disciples came together to fight the QZ7, they would win easily.

[Western Eccentric]

Rubbish.

MCF was fighting the QZ 7 and losing just by a bit.

If HYS' disciples came together to fight the QZ7, they would win easily.

That's mean MCF and co should be more powerful than HYS since HYS couldn't "break" Quanzhen Big Dipper also Zu Cong (2nd Freaks) once told to GJ that MCF skills even not reach 1/10 of HYS level which mean she and her martial arts brothers only 7-8 out of 10 HYS skills so how could with only 80% of HYS skills you could beat Quanzhen Big Dipper the thing that even 100% HYS/HYS himself can't..

[Ken Cheng]

Rubbish.

MCF was fighting the QZ 7 and losing just by a bit.

If HYS' disciples came together to fight the QZ7, they would win easily.

That's mean MCF and co should be more powerful than HYS since HYS couldn't "break" Quanzhen Big Dipper also Zu Cong (2nd Freaks) once told to GJ that MCF skills even not reach 1/10 of HYS level which mean she and her martial arts brothers only 7-8 out of 10 HYS skills so how could with only 80% of HYS skills you could beat Quanzhen Big Dipper the thing that even 100% HYS/HYS himself can't..

Indeed. The Cheun Jen 7 Disciples were testing out Mui Chiu Fung's martial arts and toying with her. If they meant to go for the quick kill against her, they easily could have.

[Eastern Heretic]

That's mean MCF and co should be more powerful than HYS since HYS couldn't "break" Quanzhen Big Dipper also Zu Cong (2nd Freaks) once told to GJ that MCF skills even not reach 1/10 of HYS level which mean she and her martial arts brothers only 7-8 out of 10 HYS skills so how could with only 80% of HYS skills you could beat Quanzhen Big Dipper the thing that even 100% HYS/HYS himself can't..

HYS could break it but he didn’t because for him to do it he had to kill those Taoist which he refused to due to his friendship with the dead WCY

[Western Eccentric]

HYS could break it but he didn’t because for him to do it he had to kill those Taoist which he refused to due to his friendship with the dead WCY

Yeah sori if HYS use sword or proper weapon he would win IMHO..

[hyoyatika]

I wasn't aware HYS' best weapon was a sword...

(Sarcasm by the way).

[Western Eccentric]

I wasn't aware HYS' best weapon was a sword...

(Sarcasm by the way).

His best weaponry skill called Jade Flute Sword which mean he could use either sword or flute depends on his "will"..