The fates of East Heretic Wong Yerk See's crippled students

[Ken Cheng]

The fates of East Heretic Wong Yerk See's students Luk Sing Fung, Kuk Ling Fung, Mo Min Fung, and Fung Mak Fung leaves a few unanswered questions, especially since they were all crippled by their teacher.

1. How did they get off Peach Blossom Island? The crippled students were unable to walk. How were they able to procure transportation to get off the island?

2. Luk Sing Fung eventually became a wealthy and powerful leader of an anti-Jin (and later, anti-Mongol) force in TaiWu. Kuk Ling Fung owned his own inn in Ox Village, where he was a neighbor of Yeung Teet Sum and Gwok Siu Teen. These activities, especially those of Luk Sing Fung's, require money. How did Luk and Kuk get this money? I'm sure Wong Yerk See didn't provide them with a stipend before banishing them, and with their legs crippled, they were in no position to steal it or hire themselves out as mercenary fighters for it. This is especially perplexing in the case of Luk Sing Fung, who had a son and must have therefore have had a wife. What woman would marry a crippled man in those days unless he was wealthy?

3. Whatever happened to Mo Min Fung? We know he died like the rest of his former martial brothers, but under what circumstances? What did he accomplish before he died?

4. Why did these four students of Wong Yerk See not stay together after being banished from the island? Given that they were all crippled, their chances of survival would probably be higher if they stayed together than if they went their separate ways. And again, how did four crippled men get so far geographically separated from each other?

[Son of Light]

1: Since HYS drove them away, he provided the transport.
2: God(IE. JY) give them money.
3: This I don't know
4: They tried to build a Tower to reach heaven, so God broke them up.

[rabadi]

Just my humble theory for number 2: Brother Luk probably went to the Big Lake (TaiWu), met the lake pirates over there, and defeated their leader, and become one (pirate leader) himself. Slowly he gathered more and more followers, built his mansion, and direct his men to form an anti-Jin/Mongol group.

[Raden Wijaya]

I feel sory for East Heretic's students. They are actually talented & good students, by means their kungfu, attitude and intellegence (except MCF & husband).
I wonder if WCY has these students, Quan Zhen sect would be fantastic (at least can handle one of 4 Greats) & made WCY proud !!!

[kidd]

Did HYS break both of his students' legs or only one?

In LOCH03, Kuk Ling Fung use one only 'kuai cheung'(sorry dunno what it's called in english), that means only one of his legs was crippled. In ROCH95, it was shown that HYS's youngest student also only has 1 leg broken. But in LOCH82, Luk Sing Fung was in a wheel chair. That means both his legs were broken.

[rabadi]

I do not remember the detail whether HYS broke one or both legs of his students, but I think that Luk Sing Fung, being in a wheelchair, could still defeat Yang Kang is quite impressive and looks cool compared to if he was using 'kuai cheung'

[Ken Cheng]

Originally posted by rabadi
I do not remember the detail whether HYS broke one or both legs of his students, but I think that Luk Sing Fung, being in a wheelchair, could still defeat Yang Kang is quite impressive and looks cool compared to if he was using 'kuai cheung'

I suppose that it's impressive that Luk Sing Fung and the other Peach Blossom Island disciples were able to fight after their crippling injuries, but Yeung Hong wasn't a very difficult opponent to overcome. Yeung Hong's martial arts never advanced beyond the Gong Nam 7 Freaks' level. Yeung Hong would not even have been able to murder Hon Bo Kui (Gong Nam Freak # 3) on Peach Blossom Island if Hon wasn't in total shock and awe over West Poison Au Yeung Fung's (in the disguise of East Heretic Wong Yerk See) quick murder of Chu Chung (Freak # 2) and Hon Siu Ying (Freak # 7).

[lilviet_grl8o8]

i have a question. one of his disciple's had a daughter -- the crazy girl, who played wth ZBT/CBT (&bit him in LOCH82) who's daughter was she? and what ever happened to LUK SING FUNG's son afterwards? did he appear in ROCH?

[Ken Cheng]

i have a question. one of his disciple's had a daughter -- the crazy girl, who played wth ZBT/CBT (&bit him in LOCH82) who's daughter was she? and what ever happened to LUK SING FUNG's son afterwards? did he appear in ROCH?

Sor Goo was the daughter of Kuk Ling Fung, who had also been acquainted with Gwok Jing and Yeung Hong's fathers, Gwok Siu Teen and Yeung Teet Sum. Before they were killed/driven from their home, Gwok and Yeung often went drinking at the tavern owned by Kuk Ling Fung (which Kuk opened after being driven out of Peach Blossom Island by his teacher).

Luk Sing Fung's son, Luk Gwoon Ying, indeed appeared in ROCH. The Heroes Conference in the city of Dai Sing Kwan was hosted at Luk's house (where he and his wife moved after Returning Clouds Manor near Lake Tai was burned to the ground by West Poison Au Yeung Fung in LOCH).

[dgfds01]

i have a question. one of his disciple's had a daughter -- the crazy girl, who played wth ZBT/CBT (&bit him in LOCH82) who's daughter was she? and what ever happened to LUK SING FUNG's son afterwards? did he appear in ROCH?

The crazy girl was Shagu, Qu Lingfeng's daughter. He was killed by Song soldiers after raiding the imperial palace.

Lu Chengfeng's son, Lu Guanying, married Cheng Yaojia (Quanzhen 7th master Sun Bu'Er's disciple). They appeared briefly in ROCH as the host to the Hero's Meet that the Golden Wheel Monk (Jinlun Fawang) crashed. They were really only mentioned once - greeting the guests with Guo Jing and Huang Rong.

[lilviet_grl8o8]

The crazy girl was Shagu, Qu Lingfeng's daughter. He was killed by Song soldiers after raiding the imperial palace.

Lu Chengfeng's son, Lu Guanying, married Cheng Yaojia (Quanzhen 7th master Sun Bu'Er's disciple). They appeared briefly in ROCH as the host to the Hero's Meet that the Golden Wheel Monk (Jinlun Fawang) crashed. They were really only mentioned once - greeting the guests with Guo Jing and Huang Rong.

oh i knew the name sounded familiar... when i watching ROCH lol. (: i loved Shagu in LOCH82 (Chan On Ying?)

[shenlong]

1. They would row off the island, and then go hope someone sees them and lends them shelter, until they can carce a wheel chair.

2. I'm sure they had some valuables on them that they could use to get a bit of money, and with that money I guess they can become entrepenuears since they can no longer practice martial arts so they have nothing better to do.

3. I really haven't read anything that hints him, so anything I say is guess work with no evidence.

4. After getting your legs broken and banashed from your home I don't think the four were in a family stick to each other mood.

[dgfds01]

Oops, looks like Ken got here before me. Late by 6 minutes.

[lilviet_grl8o8]

Sor Goo was the daughter of Kuk Ling Fung, who had also been acquainted with Gwok Jing and Yeung Hong's fathers, Gwok Siu Teen and Yeung Teet Sum. Before they were killed/driven from their home, Gwok and Yeung often went drinking at the tavern owned by Kuk Ling Fung (which Kuk opened after being driven out of Peach Blossom Island by his teacher).

Luk Sing Fung's son, Luk Gwoon Ying, indeed appeared in ROCH. The Heroes Conference in the city of Dai Sing Kwan was hosted at Luk's house (where he and his wife moved after Returning Clouds Manor near Lake Take was burned to the ground by West Poison Au Yeung Fung in LOCH).

whoa i missed your reply.. thanks yea i understand now.. (; i like Austin's potrayal in LOCH (; very handsome. hah

[odbayarb2000]

Qu Lingfeng, Lu Chengfeng, Wu Mianfeng, and Feng Mofeng were innocent.
HYS broke their both legs except from Feng Mofeng due to the his young age. He broke his only leg.

[Ian Liew]

Qu Lingfeng, Lu Chengfeng, Wu Mianfeng, and Feng Mofeng were innocent.
HYS broke their both legs except from Feng Mofeng due to the his young age. He broke his only leg.

You mean he only broke one leg? Or did Feng only have one leg to begin with?

Yeung Hong would not even have been able to murder Hon Bo Kui (Gong Nam Freak # 3) on Peach Blossom Island if Hon wasn't in total shock and awe over West Poison Au Yeung Fung's (in the disguise of East Heretic Wong Yerk See) quick murder of Chu Chung (Freak # 2) and Hon Siu Ying (Freak # 7).

That sequence of events was invented by TVB for LOCH 82. They killed off Han Xiaoying really fast because Ban Ban had left TVB and, after leaving her out of the second part, had no choice but to include her in the third part. They used an extra, and had her die without showing her face (although it was really obvious that it wasn't Ban Ban anymore.

An alternative sequence of events had Han Xiaoying as the last to die in that cave, committing suicide rather than try and fight who she perceived as Huang Yaoshi (although in LOCH 2003 OYF unmasked to taunt her, and she saw who he really was before cutting her throat with a curse). The order of death in LOCH 2003 and the manga was Zhu Chong (well, he survived until he stole YK's shoe, but he was the first to fall), Quan Jinfa, Han Baoju then Han Xiaoying in the tomb, then Nan Xiren in GJ's arms a few days later. HBJ was taken by surprise, though, although whether because it was due to running to check on his horse which just gave its deathcry, or due to the darkness I'm not too sure.

[odbayarb2000]

Yep, Ian Liew.
HYS only broke his(Feng Mofeng's) one leg. Not his only leg. Sorry for my bad English.
Feng Mofeng had a nice fair of legs to begin with. hehe

He(Feng Mofeng) reappears in ROCH who fights against LMC with heated crutch and hammer.

[Ken Cheng]

That sequence of events was invented by TVB for LOCH 82. They killed off Han Xiaoying really fast because Ban Ban had left TVB and, after leaving her out of the second part, had no choice but to include her in the third part. They used an extra, and had her die without showing her face (although it was really obvious that it wasn't Ban Ban anymore.

An alternative sequence of events had Han Xiaoying as the last to die in that cave, committing suicide rather than try and fight who she perceived as Huang Yaoshi (although in LOCH 2003 OYF unmasked to taunt her, and she saw who he really was before cutting her throat with a curse). The order of death in LOCH 2003 and the manga was Zhu Chong (well, he survived until he stole YK's shoe, but he was the first to fall), Quan Jinfa, Han Baoju then Han Xiaoying in the tomb, then Nan Xiren in GJ's arms a few days later. HBJ was taken by surprise, though, although whether because it was due to running to check on his horse which just gave its deathcry, or due to the darkness I'm not too sure.

Interesting.

Ohr Jen Ngok was the only survivor. Would you say that that was because he was the best martial artist among the Gong Nam 7 Freaks, or was he just the luckiest?

[Ren Wo Xing]

None of the above. Ouyang Feng left him alive on purpose, because

1) He was blind, and thus wouldn't be able to see for certain who the true killer was, and

2) In this way, he could stir up even more discord against Huang Yaoshi (which he did for a time, getting Guo Jing to try and kill HYS).

[Suet Seung]

Interesting.

Ohr Jen Ngok was the only survivor. Would you say that that was because he was the best marital artist among the Gong Nam 7 Freaks, or was he just the luckiest?

I forgot. How did he end up not being on Peach Blossom Island after his sworn siblings died?

Also, I never understood what history he had at that house where it was foggy and the house was burning down but he was still able to navigate the other people to safety?