Who is the strongest and most skilled disciple of Wong Yerk See/Huang Yaoshi? Did Cheng Ying's internal power and martial arts increase greatly during the 16 years?
Who is the strongest and most skilled disciple of Wong Yerk See/Huang Yaoshi? Did Cheng Ying's internal power and martial arts increase greatly during the 16 years?
I don't think Cheng Ying had certain quality to be a top-class fighter. Huang Yaoshi just felt pity for her fate and thus he decided to adopt her as his last student. I think those 4 students of Huang Yaoshi are all powerful but they may be expert in different aspects. For example, I know that one of them was good as lightness kungfu while the other was good as formation technique.Originally Posted by TommyH
should be either of the 2 disciples tat 'betrayed' him
TaZzY InC
Huang Yaoshi may have been an introverted loner, but he always seemed to enjoy the company of young women. Whether it was Mei Chaofeng, his wife, his daughter, Sha Gu or Cheng Ying.Originally Posted by Thai guy
Gees You make him sound like a sugar daddy.
I think MCF is the best. Cheng Yin is significantly better than Guo Fu. Cheng Yin was weaker than pre-dugu YG, who is lower than pre9Yin GJ. CY have progressed since then.
Mei Chaofeng was the best, but she really didn't get there by way of Peach Blossom kung fu.
Last edited by Dennis Chen; 04-30-06 at 05:30 AM.
I'd say Mei Chao Feng
1) She didn't have both legs broken, and so would have been able to practice the martial arts the best
2) She lived longer than the guy she ran off with... mind blank, i've forgotten his name
Chen Xuanfeng.
I'd say Huang Rong, if she can be considered his disciple.
If we judge solely on Peach Blossom Island kungfu, then, Mei Chaofeng and Huang Rong should be out of place here.
Then I'd say GJ is. He knows Peach blossum art.Originally Posted by IcyFox
Cheng Yin may be best then.
If we include Huang Rong and Guo Jing, then we may have to include Yang Guo as well.
lol .. it would have to be between YG and GJ then since they are both superior to HYS.Originally Posted by Thai guy
You can't say that they are superior to HYS. I believe that all Greats are more or less at the very same level and perhaps, if they battle each other, in the fair fight, that may take a day or so to know the exact result. Moroever, you need to take HYS's wits into account.Originally Posted by strife_au
Wong Yerk See/Huang Yaoshi didn't really consider Kwok Jing/Guo Jing and Yeung Gor/Yang Guo his disciples, right? But I think Cheng Ying did call Wong Yung/Huang Rong her martial sister so you could also count Wong Yung/Huang Rong in. I think you should also count the two who escaped because they learned 9Yin/9Yum Chun Ging (Is this they 9Yin we talk about?).
Yes, Cheng Ying regarded Huang Rong as her apprentice sister but Huang Rong's most apparent skill is "Dog Beating Stick Techique" which belogns to H7G.Originally Posted by TommyH
Is the 9Yum/9Yin Chun Ging that two of Wong Yerk See/Huang Yaoshi's disciples stole the 9Yin we always talk about?
Yep. Both Mei Chaofeng and Chen Xuanfeng. They stole the 9Yin manual (recited/memorize by HYS' wife) from HYS.Originally Posted by TommyH
..ext88
Ohh I see...9Yin is a manual containing a lot of martial arts. I remember one of them...9Yum/9Yin White Bone Claw!Originally Posted by Extremer88
yeap tat was one of them easier to learn skills
TaZzY InC