Crosstable of Central Ming Jiao Round Robin Duel

[Bei Rongkun]

Let's play again a round robin duel discussion. Let's start the prototype with top fighters from Central Ming Cult excluding ZWJ. With six participants we will produce 15 matches.

I proposed the following result, considering :
Fan Yao - having work with Mongolian top fighters he witness top martial arts during his service
White Eagle - actively built up his Eagle Clan mean he was actively exercise his skill
Golden Lion - full ambition to revenge and actively try to increase his power
Yang Xiao - lack concentration due to administration and love affair, less practising
Purple Dragon - roaming jianghu without real purposes and less health
Green Bat - suffered health problem during his prime time mean probably a lack time to increase his skill

I also considered ZWJ pick for his tandems against the Shaolin trio, which is Yang Xiao, Fan Yao and White Eagle, but Fan Yao is withdrawn.

Win = 1 , draw=½, lost=0

.......vs....... 1 2 3 4 5 6 Points
Fan Yao (1)..... X ½ ½ 1 1 1 =4
White Eagle (2). ½ X ½ ½ 1 1 =3.5
Golden Lion (3). ½ ½ X ½ ½ 1 =3
Yang Xiao (4)... 0 ½ ½ X 1 1 =3
Purple Dragon(5) 0 0 ½ 0 X ½ =1
Green Bat (6)... 0 0 0 0 ½ X =0.5

Fan Yao vs White Eagle ½-½
Fan Yao vs Golden Lion ½-½
Fan Yao vs Yang Xiao 1-0
Fan Yao vs Purple Dragon 1-0
Fan Yao vs Green Bat 1-0
White Eagle vs Golden Lion ½-½
White Eagle vs Yang Xiao ½-½
White Eagle vs Purple Dragon 1-0
White Eagle vs Green Bat 1-0
Golden Lion vs Yang Xiao ½-½
Golden Lion vs Purple Dragon ½-½
Golden Lion vs Green Bat ½-½
Yang Xiao vs Purple Dragon 1-0
Yang Xiao vs Green Bat 1-0
Purple Dragon vs Green Bat ½-½


I hope this is interesting.........

[athlee]

I would put PD above GL for several reasons, being:

1) PD was the strongest of the 4 guardians when it was first establish (Purple, White, Gold and then Green was the ranking)
2) GL is blind
3) GL was obsessed with the Sabre and had little time actually practising his skills on the island
4) PD was only hesitant in dealing with GL because he had the Sabre with him when she found him in the island

Based on the above, YX would also have been above GL.

[flamer]

Purple, White, Gold, Green wasn't really the martial arts ranking. Due to Dai Qisi's service and the fact that she's a woman, they let her take the No 1 spot.

The sabre compensated for XX's eyes apparently.

[Bei Rongkun]

How about assesment on the two advisors, is my appreciation on Fan Yao overrated here?

I think they all pretty balance if not they would not be rank at the same rank. But over the time, Purple D is a bit off battle, she suffer defeat under not so elite Mijue, only with an additional of Heaven sword. For Xie Xun, he is blind, and with all conflict in his mental, perhaps his skill declined a lot also.

[yittz]

Yang Xiao = Fan Yao, both great at techniques; Yang Xiao also has access to QKDNY lvl 2
Yin Tian Zheng best internal
Golden Lion's only disadvantage is his eyes, which is apparently made up for by his sabre; pre-obsession, he certain had the biggest prospect and talent to be the strongest; even in isolation his internal strength improved
Purple dragon isn't ranked first for her martial arts; her martial arts would be around green bats.