WCY vs Big Dipper formation

[Stance]

How would the man himself go against the Big Dipper Formation, if there was strong enough fighters so that the formation had no weakness.

Would he be beaten by his own creation?

[ToOn99]

WCY supposed to know the weak point of this formation since he was the creator.

[superboy]

If you put people like the Greats in it, you don't even need a formation to win.

[Anonymous]

Remember how GuoJing used his knowledge against the formation in ROCH?

[superboy]

You can sort of predict the movement if you're familiar with the formation.

[darkshineknight]

guo jing can't be stronger than WCY and yet GJ only knew the small dipper formation yet he still was able to do so well.
WCY was the creator and he has greator martial arts so ofcourse Wcy would win

[superboy]

I think there is a great possibility that GJ is stronger than WCY. He was barely able to defeat the Greats in their 30s.

[JigSta]

Originally posted by superboy
I think there is a great possibility that GJ is stronger than WCY. He was barely able to defeat the Greats in their 30s.

But the Greats in their 30's were obviously still the best of the best at that time, or else why would THEY be in the tournament for 9 yin in the first place. And how could OYF storm WCY's funeral if he wasn't already a great fighter.

[superboy]

They were the best of the best of that time, but not comparible if compare to their latter improvement.

[Ian Liew]

How would you define 'strong enough fighters'? Put seven Wang Chongyangs in the formation and the single one would die quite easily.

If you had the original Seven (including Tan Chuduan) Wang would still win since the formation had a big weakness which Huang Yaoshe (and later, Guo Jing) figured out for themselves.

Pit Wang against the aforementioned formation, and put somebody tough, say, Guo Jing or Huang Yaoshe, in the Beijixing position, and I'd say Wang might probably lose.